Italy weighs banning drivers over 85 from the road
Italy is debating revoking driving licences for people over 85. Road safety, personal independence and a slippery slope, examined.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Italy weighs revoking licences at 85: safety versus independence
The debate has landed in Italy: banning people over 85 from getting behind the wheel. There is no law yet, but the proposal already has entrenched camps. Some applaud it in the name of road safety; others see it as a confiscation of independence. And some suspect that the 85 limit is only the beginning.
The driving test is already the first filter
Before any ban, the system already has a sieve: the medical and cognitive assessment required to renew a licence. It is the natural route for sidelining those unfit to drive. It is not always popular: many older people resist it. But supporters of the measure put forward a hard argument: at certain ages, the risk is to everyone, not just the driver.
The slippery slope
The most political objection is predictable: if the state decides that at 85 you no longer drive, why not at 80? And tomorrow at 70? It is the story of many regulations: the generation without the problem today is handed the hot potato from their elders.
The data to justify it is missing
The discussion rests on a void: there are no figures on accidents caused by people over 85, nor any comparison with young drivers. Without that, the ban is just hot air. And the example that complicates things is real: a 90-year-old who drives in order to care for their family.
Experience does not equal safety, but neither does youth. A chronological cut-off is convenient; individual assessment is fair. For now, Italy is left with the question on the table.
The debate has landed in Italy: banning people over 85 from getting behind the wheel. There is no law yet, but the proposal already has entrenched camps. Some applaud it in the name of road safety; others see it as a confiscation of independence. And some suspect that the 85 limit is only the beginning.
The driving test is already the first filter
Before any ban, the system already has a sieve: the medical and cognitive assessment required to renew a licence. It is the natural route for sidelining those unfit to drive. It is not always popular: many older people resist it. But supporters of the measure put forward a hard argument: at certain ages, the risk is to everyone, not just the driver.
The slippery slope
The most political objection is predictable: if the state decides that at 85 you no longer drive, why not at 80? And tomorrow at 70? It is the story of many regulations: the generation without the problem today is handed the hot potato from their elders.
The data to justify it is missing
The discussion rests on a void: there are no figures on accidents caused by people over 85, nor any comparison with young drivers. Without that, the ban is just hot air. And the example that complicates things is real: a 90-year-old who drives in order to care for their family.
Experience does not equal safety, but neither does youth. A chronological cut-off is convenient; individual assessment is fair. For now, Italy is left with the question on the table.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (12 replies).
More summaries
-
EU-funded holm oaks cleared in Valencia for solar panels
30 hectares of holm oaks planted in 2000 with EU funds are being felled in Jalance, Valencia, to install solar panels. The case has been reported to the Guardia Civil.
-
Spain tops EU unemployment as 41% of registered jobseekers go uncounted
41% of people registered at Spanish employment offices do not count in the official unemployment figures. Spain leads the EU in real unemployment despite the statistical makeover.
-
EU Digital Identity Linked to End of Anonymity, Forum Thread Claims
A forum thread suggests the EU's Kids Act, set for Sept 17, will link digital identity to the end of online anonymity.
-
The Zaragoza eviction case that the press reported incompletely
A forum questions the narrative of a pregnant woman facing eviction in Spain, citing three children from three different fathers and a history of threats.
-
From gold to mirrors: the historical debt pitting Spain against Latin America
Calls for the return of plundered gold reignite the historic battle between those who see genocide and those who defend mestizaje. Castile, Cuba and the mirrors.
-
The cost of having a girlfriend: when she's only after your money
The debate over girlfriends who only ask for money reveals a majority stance: end the relationship. Stories from men who set boundaries and ended up alone.