Is Spain really the best country to live in?

Spain: the best country to live in? The data that debunk the myth

A young married couple, both engineers, with a child and salaries totalling €70,000 gross a year. In Madrid, after taxes, rent and childcare, they barely make it to the end of the month. In Palencia, on the same income, they save, eat out and plan a second home. The paradox is not new, but the mantra that "there's nowhere like Spain to live" clashes ever more with the reality of those trying to build a life here.

The mirage of foreign retirees

It is repeated ad nauseam: thousands of retirees from northern Europe choose Spain to retire. Irrefutable proof that life is better here. But the analysis needs nuance. Those retirees don't come to live in the full sense of the word: they aren't born here, don't train here, don't work here, don't aspire to a home on a local salary. They come to reside, to spend the winter, to buy cheap sun with pensions that double the Spanish average. They are long-stay tourists, not citizens who share the country's working conditions. Confusing the two is the first mistake of the official narrative.

Brain drain: haemorrhage or anecdote?

INE data cited in the analysis show that around 15,000 of the 32,000 annual emigrants with university degrees are Spanish. Although in absolute terms this may seem a minority, the overrepresentation is clear: while graduates make up 40% of the active population, they account for nearly 50% of those leaving. And not all profiles leave equally. Doctors, engineers, physicists and IT specialists lead the exodus, while degrees such as politics, history or philosophy stay. The result is a selective drain of human capital that, though not massive, siphons off precisely the profiles an economy needs most to grow.

The uncomfortable consensus: neither paradise nor hell

Some argue that 95% of the world is worse off, and that comparing with Nordic or Central European countries is unfair because their climate, culture and prices have also worsened. At the other extreme, critics point out that Spain is the European country where it is hardest to become independent, where the average age for buying a first home is around 41, and where most young people need family help for the deposit. Both positions have a real basis. The problem is that the triumphalist narrative hides the opportunity costs: a country that receives cohesion funds for decades and turns them into bubbles, corruption and clientelist networks cannot give lessons in good management.

The future at stake at the ballot box and in suitcases

The debate leaves an uncomfortable conclusion: Spain is not hell, but neither is it the paradise the slogan sells. For the young, trained and ambitious, the decision to stay or leave is no longer ideological but arithmetic. And as long as wages are not enough to buy a flat without parental help, and as long as doctors strike with 80% support, the mantra will sound increasingly hollow. Perhaps the true indicator is not how many retirees come, but how many young people seriously consider leaving.

Related debates in the forum

• Idealista's monthly report is out. Prices continue to rise · 10 replies
• I think the AI bubble is finally bursting. · 34 replies
• Who is more of a traitor, Zapatero or Pedro Sanchez · 25 replies
• shishi pass cancelled: seducing the judge with cleavage no longer works · 55 replies