Is cramming for Spain's university entrance exam worth it?
We look at whether the effort of Spain's Selectividad entrance exam still pays off, with data on cut-off grades, degrees with job prospects and the decline of the social ladder.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Selectividad: worthwhile effort or degree lottery?
In Spain, the traditional "social ladder" that rewarded academic effort has been broken for decades. Yet thousands of teenagers are still holed up in libraries chasing top grades. The question is whether the sacrifice is still worth it, or only makes sense for a handful of degrees such as Medicine or Engineering.
The degrees that do pay off
Defenders of the system argue that only certain degrees justify the pressure. Medicine, Nursing and Engineering still offer a clear path to employment and decent salaries. For the rest, such as Primary Education or the Humanities, the effort rarely translates into proportional rewards. Private universities, with annual fees between 7,000 and 10,000 euros, are presented as an alternative for those who can afford them.
The social ladder is broken in Spain
A recurring analysis points out that the social ladder no longer works within the country. The real return comes from emigrating to countries where degrees are valued. Meanwhile, for the rich, university access is a matter of wallet, not merit. The Selectividad only rewards poor students who manage to reach the required cut-off grade.
The uncomfortable conclusion is that, for the average student, the effort put into the Selectividad is only justified if they are aiming for a very specific degree or planning to leave Spain. Everyone else faces diminishing returns on their investment.
Related discussions in the forum
In Spain, the traditional "social ladder" that rewarded academic effort has been broken for decades. Yet thousands of teenagers are still holed up in libraries chasing top grades. The question is whether the sacrifice is still worth it, or only makes sense for a handful of degrees such as Medicine or Engineering.
The degrees that do pay off
Defenders of the system argue that only certain degrees justify the pressure. Medicine, Nursing and Engineering still offer a clear path to employment and decent salaries. For the rest, such as Primary Education or the Humanities, the effort rarely translates into proportional rewards. Private universities, with annual fees between 7,000 and 10,000 euros, are presented as an alternative for those who can afford them.
The social ladder is broken in Spain
A recurring analysis points out that the social ladder no longer works within the country. The real return comes from emigrating to countries where degrees are valued. Meanwhile, for the rich, university access is a matter of wallet, not merit. The Selectividad only rewards poor students who manage to reach the required cut-off grade.
The uncomfortable conclusion is that, for the average student, the effort put into the Selectividad is only justified if they are aiming for a very specific degree or planning to leave Spain. Everyone else faces diminishing returns on their investment.
Related discussions in the forum
- Things are getting ugly in Tehran · 80684 replies
- Why do only ugly Muslim women reach us? · 52 replies
- Wall Street pays 25,000 dollars a day to REPLACE rowers with AI · 13 replies
- Rafa Jódar flatly denies pushing a ball girl at Roland Garros: "I didn't touch her, she tripped over the tarp" · 23 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (14 replies).
More summaries
-
The social ladder is broken: no more safe career paths
99% of executives expect AI-driven layoffs. University degrees no longer guarantee social mobility. Has the social ladder broken for good?
-
The strange case of the gay medical student and his girlfriend: a social ladder?
An 18-year-old gay medical student gets a girlfriend to climb the social ladder. Breakup and drama follow. An analysis of social mobility strategies.
-
Nursing beats Medicine on return on investment
Nurses in Spain earn just €4,000 less than doctors after two fewer years of study, and out-earn engineers. How long can the healthcare salary bubble last?
-
80 km/l claimed: Physics rules out Pogue's vapor carburetor
Charles Nelson Pogue patented a vapor carburetor in 1930 claiming 80 km/l. Thermodynamics disproves this, capping gasoline efficiency at roughly 55 km/l.
-
70% of Asturias' farms have closed: what comes next for Spain?
A livestock farmer from Asturias, Spain, reports that 70% of local farms have shut down. Is this the end of traditional farming or a strategy to impose lab-grown meat?
-
Controversy as Spain's prosecutor Álvaro García Ortiz wins Christa Leem Award
Prosecutor Álvaro García Ortiz receives the Christa Leem Award despite having been convicted. Critics denounce cronyism and a lack of evidence. A case that calls the award's credibility into question.