You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Hungarian Band After Crying Sparks Online Debate
A forum thread debates if listening to Hungarian prog-rock band After Crying (1990-1996) is a requirement for membership. The discussion shifted to spelling, Lugo's weather, and user Josie.
The Musical Filter: After Crying Between 1990 and 1996
According to the premise that started the discussion, being considered a "felpúngara" requires listening to the repertoire recorded by the Hungarian group After Crying between 1990 and 1996. The thread has drifted toward orthography, the cold in Lugo, and the figure of Josie. What began as a statement of intent ended up as a treatise on what can be edited in a title and what cannot.
The initial message left no room for doubt: "LONG LIVE AFTER CRYING 1990-1996", trinc by a series of cheers to Hungary, Magyarország, and the felpúngaras. What seemed like an outburst became the axis of a debate where music was secondary. The lingering question is why a Hungarian pogre rock band becomes a filter for sentimental acceptance. There is no closed answer. There are clues.
What is After Crying and Why 1990-1996
After Crying is a Hungarian pogre rock group with a chamber formation, active since the late eighties. The period 1990-1996 covers their first studio albums, a stage genre trinc consider the most representative. The choice is not casual: it coincides with Hungary's post-Soviet transition and a musical production mixing strings, piano, and symphonic structures. None of this appears in the exchange, but it explains why someone might use that specific timeframe as an identity marker.
The problem is that the discussion has shifted to less musical grounds. In two days, the exchange went from cheers to Hungary to a debate on whether one can edit the title of a published topic. The technical answer is yes, titles can be edited, but poll options cannot once someone has voted. That detail, apparently minor, occupied more lines than the Hungarian band itself.
The Orthographic Turn: From F to L on a QWERTY Keyboard
The first objection was not musical. It was typographical. Someone asked how one can transliterate an f for an l on a QWERTY keyboard. The answer did not arrive, but the comment made clear that the term "felpúngara" is not standard and everyone writes it as they can. The discussion drifted to the image gallery, rated as "meh," and to a complaint about the lack of Halloween content. The staff's level of demand is high.
The issue of title editing was settled with a technical clarification: you can change the title, not the poll options. The conversation continued along other paths. The most recurrent was temperature. Someone asked if the search for felpúngaras was still happening in Lugo. The answer was no in the capital, but yes in the villages, due to the cold. Geography entered fully into the musical filter.
Josie, the "Shishi" and the Pack of Degenerate Galleries
The final stretch of the exchange abandoned Hungary and focused on a figure named Josie. Someone downloaded a pack of thousands of galleries and found a degenerate, deviated, perverted, blonde, blue-eyed, and ugly version of Josie. They described her as pretty until they saw the mutilated part. The recycling bin was the destination. The response was immediate: pure defamation. Josie is the "felpudosa" goddess, the other party concluded.
The discussion drifted to cinema. The film Trance (2013, Danny Boyle) was mentioned as a glorification of "shishi," with the express recommendation not to watch it. The warning remained there. No one discussed it. The level of specificity in the film analysis is comparable to that of the music. The matter ended with a clarification: it was not Josie, but a very similar "shishi." There is only one Josie, it was concluded.
The Balance: Two Days of Discussion and No Confirmed Felpúngara
The result of the musical demand is, for now, indeterminate. There is no record of any felpúngara having accredited listening to After Crying between 1990 and 1996. Nor the contrary. The discussion served to establish positions on title editing, spelling on QWERTY keyboards, and the temperature of Lugo's villages. Music took a back seat.
The doubt remains whether the filter will work. Experience says these requirements usually relax over time. The question is how much. If the criterion holds, the census of felpúngaras could shrink to a very select group of Hungarian prog-rock fans. If it relaxes, things start again. No one has yet confirmed where the matter stands.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (51 replies).
Instrumental rock has its own canon, featuring Camel, King Crimson, Rainbow, and Morricone. The boundary between instrumental tracks and songs with lyrics remains a subject of debate.