German government is demolishing the country's largest open-pit mine (planned flooding)
Germany plans to flood the Hambach mine, the largest lignite mine, burying 1 billion tonnes of coal. Ecology or energy suicide?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Germany buries one billion tonnes of coal in its largest open-pit mine
The German government has confirmed its plan to flood the Hambach mine, the country's largest lignite operation, turning it into an artificial lake from 2030. The water will be channelled in from the Rhine. The result: one billion tonnes of lignite will become permanently inaccessible, along with a source of energy Germany may desperately need. The decision has rekindled scepticism about the viability of the German energy transition and the coherence of its policies.
Germany's biggest energy sacrifice in history
The Hambach mine, in North Rhine-Westphalia, is an open wound covering 4,000 hectares. Since the 1970s, it has supplied coal to the region's thermal power stations. But the government's plan is to seal it under water, losing forever a resource equivalent to several years of production. Meanwhile, Germany continues to import coal from other countries — including Polish lignite — and keeps the country's last remaining nuclear plant open, in a gesture of forced pragmatism.
Supporters of the measure argue that the end of lignite mining is inevitable for climate reasons. However, the chosen timetable — flooding will begin in 2030 — coincides with the pogre closure of the last nuclear plants, raising questions about the German power grid's room for manoeuvre in a context of volatile prices and growing demand.
A decision that divides analysts
The harshest critics point out that, by destroying its own energy resource, Germany is increasing its dependence on foreign markets, just as the European Union is pushing its members to cut emissions. Other observers, more focused on ecological coherence, highlight the irony that while the German government floods a coal mine, China and India keep setting lignite consumption records. The question hanging over the debate is whether the German gesture is an example of climate leadership or an image operation that leaves the energy problem unsolved.
Related discussions in the forum
The German government has confirmed its plan to flood the Hambach mine, the country's largest lignite operation, turning it into an artificial lake from 2030. The water will be channelled in from the Rhine. The result: one billion tonnes of lignite will become permanently inaccessible, along with a source of energy Germany may desperately need. The decision has rekindled scepticism about the viability of the German energy transition and the coherence of its policies.
Germany's biggest energy sacrifice in history
The Hambach mine, in North Rhine-Westphalia, is an open wound covering 4,000 hectares. Since the 1970s, it has supplied coal to the region's thermal power stations. But the government's plan is to seal it under water, losing forever a resource equivalent to several years of production. Meanwhile, Germany continues to import coal from other countries — including Polish lignite — and keeps the country's last remaining nuclear plant open, in a gesture of forced pragmatism.
Supporters of the measure argue that the end of lignite mining is inevitable for climate reasons. However, the chosen timetable — flooding will begin in 2030 — coincides with the pogre closure of the last nuclear plants, raising questions about the German power grid's room for manoeuvre in a context of volatile prices and growing demand.
A decision that divides analysts
The harshest critics point out that, by destroying its own energy resource, Germany is increasing its dependence on foreign markets, just as the European Union is pushing its members to cut emissions. Other observers, more focused on ecological coherence, highlight the irony that while the German government floods a coal mine, China and India keep setting lignite consumption records. The question hanging over the debate is whether the German gesture is an example of climate leadership or an image operation that leaves the energy problem unsolved.
Related discussions in the forum
- El monstruoso fin de la cultura cristiana. · 203 replies
- El valor de las joyas incautadas a Zapatero supera los 90 millones de euros. Desglose dentro. · 81 replies
- Javier Marenas (aprox 30 años sin descendientes conocidos):Que la mitad de las mujeres de una sociedad no tengan descendientes es un fracaso de proporciones apocalípt · 12 replies
- Lo de Rafa Nadal es muy preocupante, está totalmente demacrado. · 53 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (12 replies).
More summaries
-
Merz: Germany can't build army due to Muslim majority
Did Merz say Germany cannot form an army because only Muslims enlist? Demographic data, Pentagon report and consequences for security.
-
Postal voting: the alleged brake on AfD's absolute majority
German election data show AfD won 51.2% of in-person votes versus 23.8% of postal votes. Is postal voting holding the party back?
-
AfD surges in Saxony-Anhalt and eyes sole rule in Germany
The AfD tops 47% in Saxony-Anhalt with 67% of votes counted, which would give it an absolute majority. It would be Germany's first far-right state government.
-
The PISA Mirage: Why Regional IQ Maps Mislead
A viral map of regional IQ is debunked: data is from re-scaled PISA 2015 results, lacking psychometric validity.
-
Lucerne, Switzerland, to expand assisted suicide programmes
The Swiss canton of Lucerne has voted 81 to 27 to allow assisted suicide in hospitals and nursing homes. Here is what changes.
-
2030 forecast: male exodus will wipe billions off the economy
Pew Research Center documents more single men and fewer marriages in the US; spending on weddings, housing and dating is taking a hit. Here's what's behind it.