The Funniest Movie Scenes: From Torrente to Woody Allen
What makes a shot timeless comedy? This question drives a discussion starting with the sheep scene from Everything You Always Wanted to Know About Sens* (*But Were Afraid to Ask) and ending two years later with the hair collection in La escopeta nacional. In between lies a catalog ranging from the black humor of A Clockwork Orange to the absurdity of Airplane!.
The starting point is not random. The first reference is a Woody Allen sketch comedy, making the New York director the axis of the initial segment. Bananas, Annie Hall, and its iconic dance appear as declared favorites. Unanimity lasts little: someone replies that Jerry Lewis never amused them but Woody Allen did, provoking a dry response: "The comparison is even odious." Comic taste, it becomes clear, is a minefield.
From Torrente to the Farrelly Brothers: Reclaiming Crude Humor
The central part of the exchange abandons auteur cinema and settles into gross-out comedy. Torrente 3 enters the conversation via a scene with Javier Gutiérrez, and one voice asserts that neither of the saga's first two installments could match it. The provocation works: from there, the bar drops and rises simultaneously.
Dumb and Dumber, by the Farrelly brothers, is claimed as a hilarious comedy full of funny moments. A generational comparison appears: Porky's beat American Pie hands down. It is not a discussion about technical quality, but a fight over which era knew how to laugh at itself better.
Some argue that a specific scene deserves a different place. Regarding a crude humor film, it is stated that it contains "one of the best comic scenes in cinema history due to its construction, in a pijus magnificus style." Construction weighs more than the joke.
A Clockwork Orange and Uncomfortable Black Humor
Here the ground becomes slippery. Several scenes from A Clockwork Orange are cited as comedic, including the beating of the beggar or the home invasion. The response trinc quickly: "But these are not comic or funny scenes." The defense is direct: "They seem quite funny to me, probably because I especially like black humor."
That disagreement is the most interesting of the whole. It is not discussed whether the scene is well-shot, but whether laughter is a legitimate reaction to violence. Trainspotting[/I] enters through the same door, with the job interview and Scotland's worst toilet as examples of uncomfortable surrealism.
Ghostbusters, Life of Brian, and the Shared Canon
As the exchange nears the end, titles almost nobody disputes appear. The library scene from Ghostbusters is recalled with a confession: seeing it in the cinema for the first time caused antiestéticar rather than amusement. The song from the same film completes the tribute.
Monty Python's Life of Brian is dispatched with a phrase that ends any debate: "you can quote it entirely." Airplane! contributes its favorite scene and Blues Brothers the pile of disasters. Italian comedy antiestéticaturing Jaimito, Jexi, and the bullfighting scene from the Allen movie close a journey mixing the scatological with the elegant without asking permission.
And what remains of all this? A catalog without single criteria, crossed by a suspicion: that laughter depends less on the film than on the age at which one saw it. What causes guffaws today will be a scene that does not withstand rewind tomorrow. Nobody has found the formula yet, and at this point they no longer look for it.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (108 replies).