Frugal Splurges: €140 Kindle and €200 Unlocked Phone

A €1,000 monthly budget allows for a €140 Kindle, a €200 phone, and a €2,300 car. The key is calculating amortization for every expense.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Frugal Splurges: €140 Kindle and €200 Phone

Extreme saving doesn't miccionan refusing to spend; it means subjecting spending to scrutiny. Those who claim they buy nothing end up purchasing a €140 e-reader, a €200 smartphone, or a €2,300 car, defending these choices with spreadsheets. In this school of thought, a whim isn't a pleasure: it's an investment with an amortization date.

The paradox was raised by someone who peine the discussion with a budget of €1,000 prorated monthly and confessed to two purchases: an e-reader and an unlocked smartphone. Neither were pure necessities, but both justified themselves. "Mine broke," is the summary. The rest is accounting.

The Inventory: Imported Beer, Jamón, and a €1 Raincoat

Asked about their splurges, savers return a well-optimized shopping list. Imported beers at €1 per bottle. 100 grams of serrano ham. A bottle of gin for making home cocktails, with its lime. Three chocolate bars taking advantage of a 3-for-2 deal at €1.33 per unit. A transparent bazaar raincoat for €1 for hiking.

There is also white wine at €3.50 —with doubt between that bottle and another at €4.50, and regret for having given in to waste— and a Belgian beer at €2.50 in a supermarket. The pattern repeats: pleasure exists, but it comes with a revised price tag.

Some escape to Italy for two days with their partner, leaving the children with grandparents, emphasizing it as if the destination were the sin, flying with a low-cost airline. Others book four days in a hotel in Agadir, but clarify they go for thalassotherapy. Luxury is tolerable if it comes with an excuse. Others simply surrender to the evidence: an occasional treat is not bad.

The Kindle and Amortization: €140 in Books No Longer Bought

The e-reader appears in several confessions, always with the same argument: at €20 per book, the device pays for itself in months. Savings are measured not by the gadget's price, but by what stops being spent afterward. Time is added too: no longer going down to the library is worth money, even if nobody puts it in the spreadsheet.

The public library remains the hardest counterargument. Only those who need nothing spend, some argue, and published material is dispensable, so true saving is not reading or reading for free. The discussion doesn't close, but leaves the flank open.

The same reasoning applies to video games: buying outside sales is throwing money away. With €30 accumulated from winter deals and Christmas sales, there is entertainment for six months, until the next round of discounts. Stores out of promotion? Don't even look.

Cars, Phones, and Second-Hand Bargains: When Spending Avoids Disaster

The most expensive whim came with time. A 1997 car with 330,000 kilometers that caused scares was swapped for a 2001 model with 200,000 km, for €2,300. Selling the old phone and bicycle covered €280 of that amount. Two weeks of calculations before deciding. The conclusion was blunt: it was that or continue risking an accident.

Second-hand purchases work on the same level. A bicycle that cost €750 new, acquired for €420 with six months of use. A musical instrument for €60 that came with a strap, new strings, and a hard case. Real savings lie in the entry price, but the selling point is that the asset no longer depreciates.

The other side is that of those who admit to turning their habits around, moving from spending blindly to considering every expenditure obscene. It's not an ideological conversion, they say, it's arithmetic.

The Price of Cheese and Ham: The Threshold Not Crossed

The most revealing part is setting limits. Some don't pay more than €7/kg for beef, €5 for pork, €2 for chicken, and €1 for any fruit. If it doesn't appear at that price, it isn't bought. It's not a diet: it's a pricing policy.

  • Beef: €7.00/kg
  • Pork: €5.00/kg
  • Semi-cured cheese: €5.90/kg
  • Chicken: €2.00/kg
  • Fruit: €1.00/kg

In contrast, splurging consists of cured sheep cheese at €12/kg that sweats oil and lasts months at room temperature. And there is an anecdote that summarizes the effect of years better than any graph: a consumable that cost 600 pesetas —about €3.60— in 1999 was paid €8 in the same establishment. There, frugality fails.

Negotiated Portability: €144 vs. €329

The last whim documents the entire mechanism. A high-end terminal that cost €329 in the loyalty program was closed at €144 after threatening to switch operators, with a 20% bill discount for a year. Another case points higher: 40% discount and a terminal for €19, achieved after hearing that the maximum offered was different.

The technique repeats: request portability, let the company call, and negotiate casually. The discount isn't a gift; it's the price of a credible threat to leave. The operation works better the higher the monthly consumption, which excludes those who spend little: margins are paid by the customer who stays.

With these numbers, the label of 'miser' should be applied carefully. Those who boast of not spending usually carry a catalog of perfectly reasoned purchases. The useful question isn't how much you spend, but how long it will take to recover it.

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (164 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back