Florida's economy overtakes Spain's
Florida, with 23 million residents, has now overtaken Spain in GDP. Is this a sign of Spain's decline or proof of a more efficient model? The debate on Burbuja.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Florida overtakes Spain in GDP: Spanish failure or American success?
Florida, with 23 million residents, now generates a GDP higher than Spain's, which has 48 million. The thread starts with a tweet showing the comparison, and forum users are quick to get fired up. Is this a sign of Spain's decline, or simply the reflection of a more dynamic economic model?
The figure that stings: population vs productivity
The user burbubot puts it bluntly: "Florida has 22 million mouths to feed against Spain's 48." Yet nominal GDP is already higher in the southern state. Some forum users, like Indra Ōtsutsuki, argue that California and Texas were also comparable to Spain in the 2000s, but "with the country's breakdown, Florida is overtaking you." Others, like Arturo Bloqueduro, are more direct: "Florida outperforms any third-world country." The discussion heats up when immigration and economic policies come into play.
Does the 'surplus' population matter?
ElCalvo drops: "Florida, 23 million and growing, basically the same population as Spain... where 20 million of surplus dregs are left over." This triggers a reaction from Fausto1880: "Does a Caribbean person in Florida make it grow, while in Spain they're surplus dregs?" The debate drifts toward demographic composition and quality of life, with burbubot arguing that the U.S. also has misery if you're not in the right sector.
History, flags and resentments
The thread veers into history when Douglas MacArthur points out that Florida's flag comes from the Spanish Cross of Burgundy. Indra Ōtsutsuki seizes on it: "The USA has respected Spanish origins more than the Mexicans themselves." The conversation fills with references to the Viceroyalty of New Spain and cultural identity, drifting away from GDP but showing the depth of the forum.
The thread reaches no consensus: while some see Florida as a mirror to look into, others point out that hurricane insurance and private healthcare are no paradise. Should Spain copy the model, or is it simply a misleading comparison?
Related debates on the forum
Florida, with 23 million residents, now generates a GDP higher than Spain's, which has 48 million. The thread starts with a tweet showing the comparison, and forum users are quick to get fired up. Is this a sign of Spain's decline, or simply the reflection of a more dynamic economic model?
The figure that stings: population vs productivity
The user burbubot puts it bluntly: "Florida has 22 million mouths to feed against Spain's 48." Yet nominal GDP is already higher in the southern state. Some forum users, like Indra Ōtsutsuki, argue that California and Texas were also comparable to Spain in the 2000s, but "with the country's breakdown, Florida is overtaking you." Others, like Arturo Bloqueduro, are more direct: "Florida outperforms any third-world country." The discussion heats up when immigration and economic policies come into play.
Does the 'surplus' population matter?
ElCalvo drops: "Florida, 23 million and growing, basically the same population as Spain... where 20 million of surplus dregs are left over." This triggers a reaction from Fausto1880: "Does a Caribbean person in Florida make it grow, while in Spain they're surplus dregs?" The debate drifts toward demographic composition and quality of life, with burbubot arguing that the U.S. also has misery if you're not in the right sector.
History, flags and resentments
The thread veers into history when Douglas MacArthur points out that Florida's flag comes from the Spanish Cross of Burgundy. Indra Ōtsutsuki seizes on it: "The USA has respected Spanish origins more than the Mexicans themselves." The conversation fills with references to the Viceroyalty of New Spain and cultural identity, drifting away from GDP but showing the depth of the forum.
The thread reaches no consensus: while some see Florida as a mirror to look into, others point out that hurricane insurance and private healthcare are no paradise. Should Spain copy the model, or is it simply a misleading comparison?
Related debates on the forum
- Brutaaaaaal - breaking news - Zapatero's jewels come from Sonsoles Espinosa's inheritance, right-wing whining, jojojo · 48 replies
- Hypothesis, next "stunt": Lamine Yamal detained and/or arrested at U.S. customs · 18 replies
- Details of the investigation begin to emerge: More than a hundred jewels and watches in the safe at Ferraz's office. · 427 replies
- Attention: GERTRU may be moving forward. · 32 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (43 replies).
More summaries
-
Robert Pape: US strategic defeat in Iran worse than Vietnam
Robert Pape calls the intervention in Iran the worst US strategic defeat since Vietnam, with the Strait of Hormuz under Iranian control and low-cost drones.
-
The circulating calculation: 272,000 evictions since 2017
The circulating calculation estimates over 272,000 evictions since 2017, mixing rent, squatting, and mortgages, surpassing 300,000.
-
EU top court backs Spain's amnesty law, paving the way for Puigdemont's return
The CJEU has ruled that Spain's amnesty law does not conflict with EU law. Puigdemont may return, but the Supreme Court will still decide on the embezzlement charges.
-
€50 from Spain's minimum income and food banks: the poverty trap
A testimony from Jerez, Spain, shows how the IMV minimum income drops to €50 per cohabitant, forcing people to eat at soup kitchens. The alternatives are emigrating or…
-
Spain and the Middle East: economic ties that outweigh Europe's
Spain has deep economic and historical ties with the Middle East. Trade, energy and its Roman legacy weigh more than the pro-European narrative admits.
-
Accept robbed in Barcelona: reward offered for unique guitar
Three attackers armed with iron bars robbed the band Accept's equipment on the AP-7 in Spain, taking Wolf Hoffmann's 'Rise of Chaos' guitar. The band is offering a reward.