Expanded suicide: when the media excuses a child's murder
A mother kills her daughter and the media call it 'expanded suicide'. The debate over the media's double standard and the justification of female infanticide in Spain.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
'Expanded suicide' and the media justification of infanticide
In April 2022, a mother from Gijón murdered her 6-year-old daughter to prevent the father, who had custody, from keeping her. The woman took her own life in prison a year later, before standing trial. What could have been just another case of filicide became a scandal when some media outlets described the act as "compassionate homicide" or "expanded suicide". The ensuing debate exposes a glaring asymmetry in news coverage when the perpetrator is a woman.
A term born in the press
The concept of "expanded suicide" is not a forum invention; it has been used by some journalists to describe cases in which a mother kills her children and then takes her own life, or even when she kills the children alone as an act of "liberation". In this case, the mother did not kill herself at the time, but months later, yet the label was applied anyway. The criticism focuses on the fact that this language blurs incivil responsibility and softens the crime.
A gender double standard
While the murder of children by their fathers is usually described bluntly as "filicide" or "infanticide", when the perpetrator is a woman psychological or social excuses are sought. The case of José Bretón, convicted of killing his two children, is cited as a counterpoint: he was never granted the benefit of a compassionate euphemism. The disparity is so obvious that several commentators point to a "sectarian drift" in the editorial line of certain media outlets.
The facts of the case
The child was murdered on 11 March 2022. The mother, Noemí Martínez, was jailed and took her own life in September 2023. The prosecution was seeking life imprisonment with review (a Spanish sentence known as prisión permanente revisable). The father, who had obtained custody, was left devastated, and users point out that the story barely made headlines until the biased coverage came to light.
A critical consensus
Despite differing political sensibilities, there is broad agreement that media outlets using these euphemisms are contributing to the normalisation of female violence and to an erosion of journalistic credibility. Most contributors agree that the justice system and public opinion must apply the same standard regardless of the perpetrator's sens.
The underlying question goes beyond a single case: is Spanish journalism capable of maintaining consistency when a woman commits the crime? Judging by the debate, the answer is a resounding no. As long as terms like "expanded suicide" keep being coined, trust in the media will remain undermined.
Related forum threads
In April 2022, a mother from Gijón murdered her 6-year-old daughter to prevent the father, who had custody, from keeping her. The woman took her own life in prison a year later, before standing trial. What could have been just another case of filicide became a scandal when some media outlets described the act as "compassionate homicide" or "expanded suicide". The ensuing debate exposes a glaring asymmetry in news coverage when the perpetrator is a woman.
A term born in the press
The concept of "expanded suicide" is not a forum invention; it has been used by some journalists to describe cases in which a mother kills her children and then takes her own life, or even when she kills the children alone as an act of "liberation". In this case, the mother did not kill herself at the time, but months later, yet the label was applied anyway. The criticism focuses on the fact that this language blurs incivil responsibility and softens the crime.
A gender double standard
While the murder of children by their fathers is usually described bluntly as "filicide" or "infanticide", when the perpetrator is a woman psychological or social excuses are sought. The case of José Bretón, convicted of killing his two children, is cited as a counterpoint: he was never granted the benefit of a compassionate euphemism. The disparity is so obvious that several commentators point to a "sectarian drift" in the editorial line of certain media outlets.
The facts of the case
The child was murdered on 11 March 2022. The mother, Noemí Martínez, was jailed and took her own life in September 2023. The prosecution was seeking life imprisonment with review (a Spanish sentence known as prisión permanente revisable). The father, who had obtained custody, was left devastated, and users point out that the story barely made headlines until the biased coverage came to light.
A critical consensus
Despite differing political sensibilities, there is broad agreement that media outlets using these euphemisms are contributing to the normalisation of female violence and to an erosion of journalistic credibility. Most contributors agree that the justice system and public opinion must apply the same standard regardless of the perpetrator's sens.
The underlying question goes beyond a single case: is Spanish journalism capable of maintaining consistency when a woman commits the crime? Judging by the debate, the answer is a resounding no. As long as terms like "expanded suicide" keep being coined, trust in the media will remain undermined.
Related forum threads
- Why do some very thin people eat a lot and never gain weight? · 94 replies
- NETFLIX buys the Javis' film at Cannes... the lgtb civil war as seen by the PSOE · 47 replies
- Pedro Sánchez is finished, and if he calls an election he is dead. · 79 replies
- If Zapatero's jewels come from Sonsoles' inheritance... · 27 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (60 replies).
More summaries
-
Spain's Productivity Stagnation: Why Political Inaction Persists
Spanish productivity has stalled for over two decades. Institutional designs that penalize business growth and prioritize obedience explain the structural deadlock.
-
Custody and suicide: the Córdoba case nobody wants to face
A man set himself on fire in Córdoba, Spain, after seven years without seeing his son. INE data show that 73% of suicides are male. What is…
-
Spain's Andalusian tripoint accounts for 11 of the 40 municipalities with most suicides
Eleven of Spain's 40 municipalities with the highest suicide rates are clustered in the tripoint where Córdoba, Granada and Jaén meet. Rural abandonment, climate and culture come under scrutiny.
-
US Intelligence Warns of Russian Drones in the Mediterranean
US intelligence warns of Russian drones launched from the sea in the Mediterranean. The narrative deflates and the economic cost comes into play.
-
Men paying no tax: the debate stirring up social media
A proposal to exempt men from income tax in Spain is stirring up forums. Between accusations of sexism and productivity arguments, the tax debate has taken on a gender dimension.
-
Trump threatens oil companies with DOJ unless they cut gas prices
Trump threatens oil companies with the DOJ if they don't lower gas prices. The parallel with Chávez and the Republican president's interventionism have shaken…