Euthanasia for depression set for June 24 in Spain
Krys, who suffers from depression, has scheduled her euthanasia for June 24. The case reopens the debate in Spain over the limits of the law and the shadow of the Canadian model.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Krys, depression and euthanasia: the debate opens on June 24
Krys had a date: June 24. In her own words, she will «voluntarily depart to the other side». The video she has released, asking for help to reconsider her decision, has peine Pandora's box of euthanasia for depression. Just months after the Noelia Castillo case, the debate over the limits of Spain's euthanasia law is back in the spotlight.
Depression and euthanasia: the slippery slope
Krys's case does not fit the classic profile of Spain's 2021 law, designed for serious and incurable illnesses involving physical suffering. Her diagnosis is depression. Those defending her right argue that no one should judge another person's suffering and that individual autonomy is absolute. Against them, a current of analysis warns of the risk of expanding assisted death to mental disorders: «the reality is that the system will be only too happy to rid itself of a net drain on resources», it is pointed out in the debate. The memory of Noelia Castillo, whose case also revolved around a depressive disorder, weighs as a precedent.
Canada: the frightening mirror
References to Canada have been constant throughout the discussion. In the North American country – as a linked thread denounces – euthanasia is even offered to homeless people in shelters, on the same day as the request. «But what the hell kind of aberration is this? Is that true?», one participant asked. The shadow of euthanasia as a tool of social control extends beyond borders. Those warning about the Canadian model antiestéticar Spain may trinc the same path: first for terminally ill patients, then for psychiatric conditions, later for poverty or loneliness.
The cultural machinery: Hollywood and the conditioning of minds
Some remind us that it all began much earlier. In 2004, two films – Amenábar's Mar Adentro and Clint Eastwood's Million Dollar Baby – won the Oscar while normalizing death as a way out of suffering. «A sheep-like propaganda push», some say. Columnist Juan Manuel de Prada wrote in ABC that before destroying people's lives, «we kill them compassionately». The accusation of social engineering hangs over the whole debate: the Overton window would have been peine first on our screens so that today, twenty years later, someone like Krys can request euthanasia for depression.
June 24 is just around the corner. No one yet knows whether Krys will go ahead with her plan or whether, as the author of the video interviewing her hopes, she will receive enough help to change her mind. What is clear is that the case has already laid bare the dilemma: how far does the right to die extend when the illness is in the mind?
Related debates in the forum
Krys had a date: June 24. In her own words, she will «voluntarily depart to the other side». The video she has released, asking for help to reconsider her decision, has peine Pandora's box of euthanasia for depression. Just months after the Noelia Castillo case, the debate over the limits of Spain's euthanasia law is back in the spotlight.
Depression and euthanasia: the slippery slope
Krys's case does not fit the classic profile of Spain's 2021 law, designed for serious and incurable illnesses involving physical suffering. Her diagnosis is depression. Those defending her right argue that no one should judge another person's suffering and that individual autonomy is absolute. Against them, a current of analysis warns of the risk of expanding assisted death to mental disorders: «the reality is that the system will be only too happy to rid itself of a net drain on resources», it is pointed out in the debate. The memory of Noelia Castillo, whose case also revolved around a depressive disorder, weighs as a precedent.
Canada: the frightening mirror
References to Canada have been constant throughout the discussion. In the North American country – as a linked thread denounces – euthanasia is even offered to homeless people in shelters, on the same day as the request. «But what the hell kind of aberration is this? Is that true?», one participant asked. The shadow of euthanasia as a tool of social control extends beyond borders. Those warning about the Canadian model antiestéticar Spain may trinc the same path: first for terminally ill patients, then for psychiatric conditions, later for poverty or loneliness.
The cultural machinery: Hollywood and the conditioning of minds
Some remind us that it all began much earlier. In 2004, two films – Amenábar's Mar Adentro and Clint Eastwood's Million Dollar Baby – won the Oscar while normalizing death as a way out of suffering. «A sheep-like propaganda push», some say. Columnist Juan Manuel de Prada wrote in ABC that before destroying people's lives, «we kill them compassionately». The accusation of social engineering hangs over the whole debate: the Overton window would have been peine first on our screens so that today, twenty years later, someone like Krys can request euthanasia for depression.
June 24 is just around the corner. No one yet knows whether Krys will go ahead with her plan or whether, as the author of the video interviewing her hopes, she will receive enough help to change her mind. What is clear is that the case has already laid bare the dilemma: how far does the right to die extend when the illness is in the mind?
Related debates in the forum
- Well, well... Two news stories about sensual assaults in Rentería (Bildu) hushed up by those around them... · 12 replies
- Do you consider yourselves white? Have you experienced racism in Europe's white countries because of your looks? · 362 replies
- Alba Carrillo says what some dare not say about Catalan, Galician and Basque: "Make it compulsory in schools" · 170 replies
- "I live alone in an ABANDONED VILLAGE to avoid paying rent" · 14 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (71 replies).
More summaries
-
Zapatero's Daughter's Weight Loss Sparks Ozempic Speculation
Speculation about the physical transformation of former Spanish PM Zapatero's daughter fuels debates on weight-loss drugs and image management.
-
Nearly five years in prison over an accusation his daughter now calls false
A man has spent almost five years in prison following an accusation his daughter now says was false. The case reopens the debate over the presumption of innocence.
-
Oporto or Porto: the debate over foreign city names in Spanish
A forum user asks whether using the traditional Spanish name for foreign cities is fascist. The thread debates Oporto versus Porto and other place names.
-
Plastic ponchos for the JANTAVIRUS drill and more botched work... a circus
Images from a simulated emergency show authorities using plastic bags as PPE, with no gloves or masks. Criticism over the lack of protocols.
-
Madrid municipal police find 600 kilos of cocaine after chasing a suspicious car
Madrid's municipal police seized 600 kilos of cocaine after a chase in Vallecas, Spain. We look at the details and the questions surrounding the operation.
-
Retired woman and wasp nest: the hoax slipping into Spain's squatting crisis
A retired woman allegedly threw a wasp nest at squatters in Barcelona: the story went viral but there is no evidence. We examine the pattern of squatting hoaxes.