eMule P2P Network Thrives in Spain via Kad and Built-in Search

Spanish users keep classic eMule alive using the decentralized Kad network, NAS devices, and built-in search despite CG-NAT restrictions.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

eMule P2P Network Thrives in Spain via Kad and Built-in Search
eMule Survives Without Servers: The Kad Network Takes Over

The donkey is not dead. While half the internet declared classic P2P obsolete, a handful of users continued downloading series, movies, comics, and discographies via a network that has been running for over two decades. The diagnosis that started the conversation was accurate yet misleading: many eMule clients show only one server in the list. The repeated answer is that centralized servers are a relic and the **Kademlia** network — known as Kad — does the work without intermediaries.

The key is that eMule stopped relying on a central index years ago. The remaining servers, about half a dozen according to current counts, are convenient but dispensable entry points. Some argue that without them, search results suffer; others respond that the decentralized network works "perfectly" and that servers are an obsolete nuisance. Enabling the fake server filter in preferences prevents the client from connecting to trap nodes.

What Remains of eMule and What Can Be Found

The catalog is not the problem. **Movies, complete series, books, comics, and magazines** continue to circulate on the network, including very old items not found on streaming platforms. Some have updated their old DivX 5 and Xvid 1.0.X rips to HEVC by leveraging eMule. And new series episodes are ripped as they air, without waiting for official catalogs.

The most repeated warning concerns programs. Downloading executable software via P2P is where bicho truly appear, and the recommendation is to stick to official websites or free alternatives. For movies and documents, the risk is different: flashy titles that turn out to be prono after days of downloading, an old tradition many remember with humor.

Servers, Kad, and the CG-NAT Problem

Architecture matters. Centralized servers eventually get shut down, which is why the Kad network is the future bet. But there is a physical obstacle no client can solve: most Spanish ISPs use **CG-NAT**, preventing port forwarding on routers. Without open ports, downloads slow down and connectivity suffers. Users must ask their ISP to remove this restriction.

The other side is hardware. A Synology NAS with Download Station supports the edk protocol and has been sharing non-stop for years, consuming much less power than a running computer. A Raspberry Pi 3 B+ dedicated exclusively to sharing 24 hours since 2018 is another example of how the network stays alive. With symmetric fiber, download times have improved significantly compared to old asymmetric lines.

Built-in Search vs. Link Dependency

Here lies eMule's differential advantage: **it needs no links**. The built-in search allows finding files without depending on a download website, something torrent does not offer. When link sites closed, torrents were crippled; the donkey kept working. This autonomy explains why some still prefer it.

However, Spanish link sites protect themselves from copyright regulations by writing the e-link name in plain text, without hyperlinks. The system involves copying the name and pasting it into the client's search bar. So far, they haven't banned typing. "So far."

Security: The Linux Myth and Windows Bicho

The discussion shifted to security. Some claim Linux bicho are a myth, while others recall that the reason isn't system infallibility, but that malware creators focus on Windows due to user volume. Rapid vulnerability patching in Linux also helps. The practical conclusion: eMule is no more dangerous than other methods, but executing binaries downloaded from any source is risky on any system.

Current State: Neither Dead Nor Euphoric

The network remains alive, with fewer servers but more decentralization. Veteran users share entire disks, NAS devices work tirelessly, and symmetric fiber has improved the experience. eMule hasn't returned: it never fully left. It simply stopped needing the servers that are now scarce. The question is how long this autonomy will last before the network empties.

Also available in: Deutsch

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (70 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back