Could a military uprising happen in Spain?
Rumours of military mobilisation and growing discontent fuel debate in Spain over a possible uprising. Is it a real possibility or pure fantasy?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The barracks conspiracy: could a general take up arms?
Rumours are circulating about a possible mobilisation of the army, and the murmur is growing in discontented circles: the idea that some senior commander might seize the reins. But is there any real basis for that hope, or is it pure tavern talk?
An analysis of the opposing positions paints a bleak picture for those dreaming of an uprising. On one side are those who believe the situation has deteriorated so badly that military intervention is the only way out. A retired general is even mentioned as a hypothetical leader. On the other side, the sceptics argue that today's commanders are, above all, civil servants: they care more about their pay and pensions than about territorial integrity. The top brass has been carefully selected from among the most docile, and no serving officer will risk his status for a pipe dream.
Some point out that the army is no longer what it once was: military values have been replaced by public-sector culture. And although some point to recent mobilisations, the dominant reading is that these are routine manoeuvres, not the prelude to a coup. For now, the conclusion is that a general's uprising belongs more to wishful thinking than to probability. The analysis keeps circling back to the same question: if the situation deteriorates further, will anyone be willing to take the plunge, or will it all come to nothing?
Rumours are circulating about a possible mobilisation of the army, and the murmur is growing in discontented circles: the idea that some senior commander might seize the reins. But is there any real basis for that hope, or is it pure tavern talk?
An analysis of the opposing positions paints a bleak picture for those dreaming of an uprising. On one side are those who believe the situation has deteriorated so badly that military intervention is the only way out. A retired general is even mentioned as a hypothetical leader. On the other side, the sceptics argue that today's commanders are, above all, civil servants: they care more about their pay and pensions than about territorial integrity. The top brass has been carefully selected from among the most docile, and no serving officer will risk his status for a pipe dream.
Some point out that the army is no longer what it once was: military values have been replaced by public-sector culture. And although some point to recent mobilisations, the dominant reading is that these are routine manoeuvres, not the prelude to a coup. For now, the conclusion is that a general's uprising belongs more to wishful thinking than to probability. The analysis keeps circling back to the same question: if the situation deteriorates further, will anyone be willing to take the plunge, or will it all come to nothing?
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (29 replies).
More summaries
-
Spanish Army debate: discipline, NATO and reform
Analysis of perceptions of the Spanish Army: from internal structure and promotions to the critical debate on its role in NATO
-
Spain vs France: 2.5 million Muslims and no neighbourhoods to riot in
Spain has 2.5 million Muslims (5.2%) compared with France's 5-7 million (7.2-10%). The debate over whether riots like France's could erupt here…
-
The A joins the LGTBIQ+ acronym as asexual community gains visibility
Asexuality has been added to the LGTBIQA+ acronym after the first Pride block in 2017. Definition, reactions and the debate over the community's boundaries.
-
End of online anonymity: mandatory verification is coming
X is already requiring facial verification from European users. A new identity app will arrive after the summer. Is this the end of anonymity on social media? An analysis of the plan and its…
-
16 stillborn babies found in basement: mother pregnant again in the US
A woman in the United States is reported to have given birth to 16 stillborn babies in a basement and is now pregnant again. The case that is horrifying the world.
-
Wasp honey, the new ragebait taking over social media
An anonymous trans person claims they want to try wasp honey, a substance worth 16,000 points. The ragebait behind the viral post and its implications.