The Class Photo Video Mixing AI, Filters, and Surgery
A video pairs yearbook photos of several girls with adult versions of their faces. There's no mystery: time, cameras, and editing. The reaction, however, has been the usual. A handful of sweeping statements about how Spanish beauty has changed and a refrain that returns every few months: hypergamy, the narrative that partners are increasingly chosen based on physical attractiveness, ultimately leaving a mark on the next generation. The problem is that almost everything being compared is a low-quality photo against a retouched one.
Has the Face of the Classroom Really Changed?
The starting point is a perception. Those who compare recall sharing a desk with one or two female classmates they admired, and claim that today this number has multiplied to fill the entire classroom. There's no census, no study, no measurement to support this leap. What has changed, and is tangible, is everything surrounding the photo: makeup, lighting, filters, and retouching are present in any image published today. Comparing a yearbook from twenty years ago with a recent Instagram photo is like comparing a sandwich to a photo of a sandwich.
The Edit That Might Be Backwards
Here comes reasonable doubt. What if the video doesn't show a before and after, but a 'made-up' after of the before? Some argue that several youthful faces were fabricated with generative AI, rejuvenating adult faces to fit a yearbook that perhaps never existed. This is the most repeated hypothesis and the hardest to debunk: if a face can be edited, it can be invented entirely. The old habit of looking at a photo and believing it is broken, and there's no going back.
Retouching, Filters, and Surgery as the Baseline
The other factor no one disputes is the prior work. Social media has raised the baseline for what's considered presentable: half an hour of preparation for an image that a generation ago wasn't even considered. And when a filter isn't enough, a consultation trinc. Cosmetic surgery has ceased to be an isolated case to become, in certain circles, a routine renovation. This doesn't make anyone more naturally attractive; it makes the photo turn out better. It's the distance between the face and its product.
Elite School: Aesthetics as a Class Marker
And then there's the variable the video downplays: selection. The images don't come from just any high school. Institutions with gyms, nutritionists, and orthodontics from age twelve produce a different result, not by DNA magic but by money and habit. Comparisons based on origin and surnames also emerged, but they don't stand up to analysis: prejudices wrapped in biology. Behind the video lies, above all, a social class that photographs well.
Ultimately, the striking fact is simple: the current comparison pits 'one or two classmates' from the nineties against the entire class today, and no one has thought to ask how many of those faces went through an app before reaching the screen. The answer, most likely, would make both sides uncomfortable.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (86 replies).
Real Madrid dominates European football but struggles against a domestic league marked by controversial refereeing decisions and the narrative hegemony of FC Barcelona.