Clara Campoamor's unpublished letter shatters the left's narrative
An unpublished letter from Clara Campoamor reveals she wanted Franco to win: she hated the Popular Front and communism. The book 'Letra de Mujer' dismantles the myth.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Clara Campoamor: the feminist republican who wanted Franco to win
An unpublished letter from the suffragist Clara Campoamor has shattered the monolithic narrative the left has built around her figure. In the letter, dated during the Spanish Civil War, the republican MP confesses her "ardent desire" for Franco to defeat the Popular Front, which she calls a "sectarian and destructive political construct". The correspondence, included in the book 'Letra de Mujer' (Editorial Renacimiento), shows a Campoamor relentless with communism, which she saw as a "direct threat against liberal democracy".
The Popular Front, in her own words
Campoamor did not mince her words. She described the Popular Front as a sectarian coalition where those outside were labelled fascists and those inside could not leave without serious consequences. For her, this polarising drift had pushed Spain into the abyss. The letter breaks with the image of a Campoamor "domesticated" by today's left, which usually omits these criticisms.
A threat against liberal democracy
The author of women's suffrage in Spain was emphatic: communism was not pogre, but a destructive force that would only bring violence and persecution. In this context, she expressed her hope that Franco's uprising would prevent Spain's definitive collapse. A statement that today is uncomfortable both for the left and for those who idealise the Second Republic.
The silence over historical contradictions
The publication of 'Letra de Mujer' has peine the debate on historical memory. While some sectors demand rewriting the tributes to Campoamor —the Chamartín station bears her name—, others argue that a democratic figure can be critical of her contemporaries without losing her legacy. The question that remains: will the left dare to accept that Campoamor was never theirs?
Related discussions in the forum
An unpublished letter from the suffragist Clara Campoamor has shattered the monolithic narrative the left has built around her figure. In the letter, dated during the Spanish Civil War, the republican MP confesses her "ardent desire" for Franco to defeat the Popular Front, which she calls a "sectarian and destructive political construct". The correspondence, included in the book 'Letra de Mujer' (Editorial Renacimiento), shows a Campoamor relentless with communism, which she saw as a "direct threat against liberal democracy".
The Popular Front, in her own words
Campoamor did not mince her words. She described the Popular Front as a sectarian coalition where those outside were labelled fascists and those inside could not leave without serious consequences. For her, this polarising drift had pushed Spain into the abyss. The letter breaks with the image of a Campoamor "domesticated" by today's left, which usually omits these criticisms.
A threat against liberal democracy
The author of women's suffrage in Spain was emphatic: communism was not pogre, but a destructive force that would only bring violence and persecution. In this context, she expressed her hope that Franco's uprising would prevent Spain's definitive collapse. A statement that today is uncomfortable both for the left and for those who idealise the Second Republic.
The silence over historical contradictions
The publication of 'Letra de Mujer' has peine the debate on historical memory. While some sectors demand rewriting the tributes to Campoamor —the Chamartín station bears her name—, others argue that a democratic figure can be critical of her contemporaries without losing her legacy. The question that remains: will the left dare to accept that Campoamor was never theirs?
Related discussions in the forum
- Voting and having a vvife in this country are mental illnesses but they are not considered as such because you are all mental patients. Detailed explanation · 18 replies
- Syria has rejected Germany's plan to return more than 700,000 Syrian refugees to their country of origin. · 144 replies
- Atapuerca News: a man is having a drink on a terrace in Santander, a minor walks up and punches him.. · 82 replies
- BULLFIGHTING CORNER II · 7971 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (56 replies).
More summaries
-
Jury convicts Spanish man who shot dead two intruders at his Alhaurín de la Torre estate
A jury convicts the owner of a Spanish estate who shot two armed intruders dead in 2009. Was self-defence denied because of his past? The case reopens the debate over Spain's self-defence laws.
-
The Spanish Flag Bracelet: An Ideological Litmus Test
A video from a date brings back the debate about the Spanish flag and its use as an ideological litmus test.
-
PNV Bilbao Candidate Mikel Hidalgo Marries His Partner
Mikel Hidalgo, the PNV candidate for mayor of Bilbao, marries his partner at 33 and announces it on social media.
-
Why the Spanish sportswear brand Joma is named after a son
How Fructuoso López founded Joma in 1965 and why the Spanish sportswear brand carries the name of his first son, José Manuel. A story of entrepreneurship and legacy.
-
Broncano drops below double digits: 1,149,000 viewers and 9.4% share vs Horizonte
La Revuelta draws 1,149,000 viewers and a 9.4% share, falling below double digits, while Horizonte beats it by nearly 250,000 viewers in the same slot.
-
Teen stabbed to death in the UK while police handcuffed him as he bled out
An 18-year-old is stabbed to death in the UK and police handcuff the victim as he bleeds out. We examine the case and the debate over public safety and bias.