Casting of the new Harry Potter splits the fandom
The actor who will play Harry Potter in the new HBO series has been criticized for his androgynous look. Is it fair to judge a child? We take a look at the controversy.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The new Harry Potter sparks a debate over his looks
The choice of the actor who will play Harry Potter in the new HBO series has triggered a wave of criticism on social media. Many users feel the young performer looks too androgynous, far removed from the image of the literary character. Others, however, point out that the original actor, Daniel Radcliffe, was hardly a model of masculinity at eleven either.
A look that divides the fans
The criticism centers on the fact that the new actor looks like a girl, with soft antiestéticatures and an expression some describe as an "old face." But others argue that he is a very young child and that his appearance will change with adolescence. The comparison with the character of Snape, who was also criticized for his looks, is inevitable. The truth is that a character's portrayal goes beyond physical appearance, and the acting will determine whether the casting was the right call.
The Daniel Radcliffe precedent
When it was announced that Daniel Radcliffe would play Harry Potter, there were doubts too. The actor did not exactly resemble the character from the books, but his performance ended up winning most people over. The same will likely happen with the new actor, provided the script and direction deliver.
In any case, the controversy reflects how hard it is to adapt iconic characters. Fans have a very fixed mental image, and any deviation triggers rejection. But history shows that time and the quality of the product usually put things right. It remains to be seen whether the actor will live up to expectations, but if the saga teaches anything, it's that appearances can be deceiving.
The choice of the actor who will play Harry Potter in the new HBO series has triggered a wave of criticism on social media. Many users feel the young performer looks too androgynous, far removed from the image of the literary character. Others, however, point out that the original actor, Daniel Radcliffe, was hardly a model of masculinity at eleven either.
A look that divides the fans
The criticism centers on the fact that the new actor looks like a girl, with soft antiestéticatures and an expression some describe as an "old face." But others argue that he is a very young child and that his appearance will change with adolescence. The comparison with the character of Snape, who was also criticized for his looks, is inevitable. The truth is that a character's portrayal goes beyond physical appearance, and the acting will determine whether the casting was the right call.
The Daniel Radcliffe precedent
When it was announced that Daniel Radcliffe would play Harry Potter, there were doubts too. The actor did not exactly resemble the character from the books, but his performance ended up winning most people over. The same will likely happen with the new actor, provided the script and direction deliver.
In any case, the controversy reflects how hard it is to adapt iconic characters. Fans have a very fixed mental image, and any deviation triggers rejection. But history shows that time and the quality of the product usually put things right. It remains to be seen whether the actor will live up to expectations, but if the saga teaches anything, it's that appearances can be deceiving.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (20 replies).
More summaries
-
Netflix Casts Black Actor as Hannibal Barca: Historical Error?
Netflix's upcoming film on Hannibal Barca sparks debate over casting choices and the historical ethnicity of Carthaginian elites.
-
Basque Country: Vice-President Links Basque Immersion to PISA Failure
Basque Vice-President Ibone Bengoetxea links the effort to teach in Basque to the Basque Country's poor PISA results, amid the fallout from the collapse in student performance.
-
Donald Trump Slams Harry and Meghan After Their Return to the UK: “If I Were in the Royal Family, I Wouldn't Have Accepted Them”
Donald Trump criticizes Harry and Meghan, stating he wouldn't have accepted them if he were part of the royal family. Discover his reasons.
-
Nando el Hispano declares humanity a fake species and shuts it down
Nando el Hispano signs a manifesto branding the human being an "aberrant and cowardly specimen" and closes down the species without offering a single piece of evidence.
-
Die Hard 3 and the debate over retroactive wokeness
An overweight cop and a Black driver save the day while the executives are the villains: the cast of 'Die Hard: With a Vengeance' reopens the culture war.
-
Vox and immigration: the U-turn splitting its voter base
A tweet claims Vox is starting to soften its immigration rhetoric and that the right will end up more pro-immigration. The economic argument divides opinion.