Cash Converters: paying 20 euros for a monitor they sell for 180
User testimonials and calculations reveal how little Cash Converters pays: up to 80% below market value. Alternatives for selling without losing money.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Cash Converters: the business of buying cheap and selling dear
Is it worth selling to Cash Converters? The answer, based on accumulated experience, is a resounding no. Testimonials from people who have tried to offload musical instruments, electronics or household goods at this second-hand buy-and-sell chain all point to the same pattern: the offer they receive is far below the item's market value, sometimes up to 80% less. The most striking case: a computer monitor bought for 20 euros appeared in the shop the next day on sale for 180 euros. An 800% margin that explains why the business works for the company and not for the seller.
The chain, with locations across Spain, has become the last resort for those who need cash immediately. But the price of that immediacy is high. For a bass guitar and several effect pedals valued at 150, 100 and 200 euros, the offer will probably not exceed a third of that amount. Cash Converters is not a second-hand shop, it is a pawnshop in disguise with a display window.
How much does Cash Converters pay for a second-hand item?
The range used by buy-and-sell shops like Cash Converters, Second Company and the like usually sits at around a third of the retail price of the item new. If the product is old or discontinued, the figure drops even further. A guitar bought second-hand for 200 euros was valued years later at 80 euros; it was finally sold to a private buyer for 150. An amplifier valued at 40 euros received an offer of 14. The proportion repeats itself: between 30% and 35% of the reasonable value.
The calculation is not arbitrary. The company assumes the risk that the item will not sell, the cost of shop space and the legal warranty it must provide. But the size of the discount far exceeds what a private seller would accept in a direct negotiation. The asymmetry is brutal: the seller needs the money, the shop does not need the item.
There are exceptions. Highly sought-after items, such as recent smartphones or consoles, may receive somewhat more generous offers. But even in those cases, the resale margin exceeds 100%. The general rule is clear: if you are not in a hurry, do not sell there.
The clientele of pawn shops: who sells and who buys
The profile of the seller who goes to these shops is someone in financial distress. The need for immediate cash —to cover a payment, a debt or simply to make it to the end of the month— drastically reduces their bargaining power. Desperation is Cash Converters' main asset.
On the other side of the counter, the buyer is looking for bargains. And finds them. A pair of binoculars worth 40 euros, new and boxed, for 15. A slide projector for 12. A 5-megapixel Canon camera with a 2 GB memory card for 12 euros. For the buyer, paradise; for the seller, purgatory.
Life inside these shops is another chapter altogether. Scenes are described of people negotiating at the door, staff passing the buck, customers haggling over five euros for twenty minutes. An ecosystem where need and opportunity cross paths.
Alternatives for selling musical instruments and electronics
The overwhelming conclusion is that there are far more profitable channels. Milanuncios stands out as the most effective platform for selling musical instruments, trinc by Segundamano, eBay and specialist forums like Hispasonic. The price difference between selling to a private buyer and underselling at a shop can triple your earnings.
For musical instruments, music schools, rehearsal spaces and secondary schools are natural points of sale. A bass guitar and several effect pedals have a specific audience that never sets foot in a general shop. Posting ads in those environments usually gets results within days.
The experience of those who have taken this route is consistent: an item sold on Milanuncios received an offer within days and payment was closed quickly. No middlemen, no abusive haggling, no feeling of having been ripped off.
The business of buying cheap and selling dear: scam or model?
Legally, there is no scam. The company offers a price and the seller accepts or declines. The problem is the information asymmetry and the pressure of need. The model relies on the seller having neither the time nor the resources to look for alternatives.
Some testimonials point to questionable practices: items rejected as "old" that later appear in the display window, valuations that vary depending on the employee, far-fetched arguments for not buying. The perception of a scam is subjective, but the feeling of having been cheated is a recurring one.
The question is not whether Cash Converters is legal, but whether it is ethical. And there, everyone decides for themselves. What is clear is that, if you can wait, selling on your own will always be more profitable. If you cannot wait, you know the drill.
In the end, the decision is simple: if you value your time and your money, avoid Cash Converters. If you value immediacy, pay the price. And don't complain about it later.
Is it worth selling to Cash Converters? The answer, based on accumulated experience, is a resounding no. Testimonials from people who have tried to offload musical instruments, electronics or household goods at this second-hand buy-and-sell chain all point to the same pattern: the offer they receive is far below the item's market value, sometimes up to 80% less. The most striking case: a computer monitor bought for 20 euros appeared in the shop the next day on sale for 180 euros. An 800% margin that explains why the business works for the company and not for the seller.
The chain, with locations across Spain, has become the last resort for those who need cash immediately. But the price of that immediacy is high. For a bass guitar and several effect pedals valued at 150, 100 and 200 euros, the offer will probably not exceed a third of that amount. Cash Converters is not a second-hand shop, it is a pawnshop in disguise with a display window.
How much does Cash Converters pay for a second-hand item?
The range used by buy-and-sell shops like Cash Converters, Second Company and the like usually sits at around a third of the retail price of the item new. If the product is old or discontinued, the figure drops even further. A guitar bought second-hand for 200 euros was valued years later at 80 euros; it was finally sold to a private buyer for 150. An amplifier valued at 40 euros received an offer of 14. The proportion repeats itself: between 30% and 35% of the reasonable value.
The calculation is not arbitrary. The company assumes the risk that the item will not sell, the cost of shop space and the legal warranty it must provide. But the size of the discount far exceeds what a private seller would accept in a direct negotiation. The asymmetry is brutal: the seller needs the money, the shop does not need the item.
There are exceptions. Highly sought-after items, such as recent smartphones or consoles, may receive somewhat more generous offers. But even in those cases, the resale margin exceeds 100%. The general rule is clear: if you are not in a hurry, do not sell there.
The clientele of pawn shops: who sells and who buys
The profile of the seller who goes to these shops is someone in financial distress. The need for immediate cash —to cover a payment, a debt or simply to make it to the end of the month— drastically reduces their bargaining power. Desperation is Cash Converters' main asset.
On the other side of the counter, the buyer is looking for bargains. And finds them. A pair of binoculars worth 40 euros, new and boxed, for 15. A slide projector for 12. A 5-megapixel Canon camera with a 2 GB memory card for 12 euros. For the buyer, paradise; for the seller, purgatory.
Life inside these shops is another chapter altogether. Scenes are described of people negotiating at the door, staff passing the buck, customers haggling over five euros for twenty minutes. An ecosystem where need and opportunity cross paths.
Alternatives for selling musical instruments and electronics
The overwhelming conclusion is that there are far more profitable channels. Milanuncios stands out as the most effective platform for selling musical instruments, trinc by Segundamano, eBay and specialist forums like Hispasonic. The price difference between selling to a private buyer and underselling at a shop can triple your earnings.
For musical instruments, music schools, rehearsal spaces and secondary schools are natural points of sale. A bass guitar and several effect pedals have a specific audience that never sets foot in a general shop. Posting ads in those environments usually gets results within days.
The experience of those who have taken this route is consistent: an item sold on Milanuncios received an offer within days and payment was closed quickly. No middlemen, no abusive haggling, no feeling of having been ripped off.
The business of buying cheap and selling dear: scam or model?
Legally, there is no scam. The company offers a price and the seller accepts or declines. The problem is the information asymmetry and the pressure of need. The model relies on the seller having neither the time nor the resources to look for alternatives.
Some testimonials point to questionable practices: items rejected as "old" that later appear in the display window, valuations that vary depending on the employee, far-fetched arguments for not buying. The perception of a scam is subjective, but the feeling of having been cheated is a recurring one.
The question is not whether Cash Converters is legal, but whether it is ethical. And there, everyone decides for themselves. What is clear is that, if you can wait, selling on your own will always be more profitable. If you cannot wait, you know the drill.
In the end, the decision is simple: if you value your time and your money, avoid Cash Converters. If you value immediacy, pay the price. And don't complain about it later.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (53 replies).
More summaries
-
Used petrol car with 150,000 km: bargain or money pit?
A 150,000 km Mégane for €1,200 or a Clio for €1,000 versus a new Sandero at €6,390. Key tips on whether an old petrol engine can handle 40 km a day.
-
Selling second-hand in Spain: bargaining and flea markets
Bargaining by half, scrap exchanges, and buyers who leave messages on read: this describes second-hand selling in Spain.
-
High-Mileage BMW or Mercedes: The €3,000 Gamble
A driver considers buying a 2004-2008 BMW or Mercedes with over 200,000 km for €2,000-€5,000. Premium maintenance costs are the hidden expense.
-
Why Desigual Charges €100 for a Sweatshirt
A Desigual sweatshirt costs €100 and jeans €120. For many users, the price is set by the label and brand, not the fabric.
-
Sans Segarra: 600 million views and his 'supraconsciousness' theory
Sans Segarra, an 83-year-old retired surgeon, fills theatres with his theory of supraconsciousness: 600 million views and hundreds of thousands of books sold.
-
Dehumidifiers: why a higher price doesn't mean better performance
Forum experiences: one user claims a sub-€100 LG outperforms a Delonghi costing twice as much. Minimum operating temperature and noise are the key factors.