Brussels demands Spain raise hospitality VAT to 21%, warns of €7 billion shortfall
Brussels is pushing Spain to raise hospitality VAT to 21% over a €7 billion tax gap. The measure would be catastrophic for the sector and would send prices soaring.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Brussels tightens the screws on hospitality: 21% VAT or a €7 billion hole
The European Commission has singled out hotels and restaurants as the sectors where reduced VAT rates generate the least social benefit and the highest cost to public coffers. The demand is clear: raise hospitality VAT to 21%, or Spain will have to explain where it will find €7 billion. The warning comes at the height of the tourist season, with the sector still recovering from recent shocks.
A ticking time bomb for bars and restaurants
The hospitality industry association calls the measure "catastrophic". And no wonder: the direct impact would miccionan an immediate rise in prices. If a café con leche costs €1.80 today with the reduced VAT rate, moving to 21% would push it to around €2.10. A €3 beer would go up to €3.60. In a country where eating on terraces is practically a national sport, the reaction was swift: some predict "€6 beers" and "€10 potato salad tapas". Others simply advocate taking the party to the park.
Brussels, the enemy within
The debate goes beyond economics. For many, Brussels' interference is the final nail in the coffin of fiscal sovereignty. "Brussels is the number one enemy of 450 million Europeans", reads one comment in the discussion. Others, more pragmatic, point out that the problem is not the EU but the quality of the leaders Spanish voters choose every four years. The recurring question is: who would this hike really benefit? Because if the goal is to raise more revenue, increasing VAT in a sector with tight margins could trigger closures and lower consumption, reducing revenue. Ironies of fiscal life.
Thanks to reduced VAT rates, Spain's hospitality sector has been a haven of affordable prices. But Brussels believes that benefit does not translate into lower costs for the end consumer, but into higher margins for the industry. The European Commission argues there are sectors with better arguments for keeping reduced rates, such as electricity or fuels. In fact, one commenter suggests: "Raise hospitality VAT (let the tourists pay) and lower it for electricity and fuel". But, as always, "that will never happen".
Related discussions in the forum
The European Commission has singled out hotels and restaurants as the sectors where reduced VAT rates generate the least social benefit and the highest cost to public coffers. The demand is clear: raise hospitality VAT to 21%, or Spain will have to explain where it will find €7 billion. The warning comes at the height of the tourist season, with the sector still recovering from recent shocks.
A ticking time bomb for bars and restaurants
The hospitality industry association calls the measure "catastrophic". And no wonder: the direct impact would miccionan an immediate rise in prices. If a café con leche costs €1.80 today with the reduced VAT rate, moving to 21% would push it to around €2.10. A €3 beer would go up to €3.60. In a country where eating on terraces is practically a national sport, the reaction was swift: some predict "€6 beers" and "€10 potato salad tapas". Others simply advocate taking the party to the park.
Brussels, the enemy within
The debate goes beyond economics. For many, Brussels' interference is the final nail in the coffin of fiscal sovereignty. "Brussels is the number one enemy of 450 million Europeans", reads one comment in the discussion. Others, more pragmatic, point out that the problem is not the EU but the quality of the leaders Spanish voters choose every four years. The recurring question is: who would this hike really benefit? Because if the goal is to raise more revenue, increasing VAT in a sector with tight margins could trigger closures and lower consumption, reducing revenue. Ironies of fiscal life.
Thanks to reduced VAT rates, Spain's hospitality sector has been a haven of affordable prices. But Brussels believes that benefit does not translate into lower costs for the end consumer, but into higher margins for the industry. The European Commission argues there are sectors with better arguments for keeping reduced rates, such as electricity or fuels. In fact, one commenter suggests: "Raise hospitality VAT (let the tourists pay) and lower it for electricity and fuel". But, as always, "that will never happen".
Related discussions in the forum
- Difference between today's workers and the slaves of antiquity? · 17 replies
- damn, the TITS Carmen Porter has on right now on Cuatro TV · 41 replies
- SKYNET IS HERE. Robot bursts a 4-year-old child's stomach · 50 replies
- This is what you find when you set foot in Switzerland · 48 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (20 replies).
More summaries
-
Spanish government knew about the migration crisis: €25 million approved in 24 hours
The €25 million allocation approved within 24 hours shows the Spanish government knew about the migration crisis. 80% goes to party-linked NGOs. A critical analysis.
-
Spain's €309 million plan for Ceuta raises doubts over delivery
Spain's 309 million euro plan for Ceuta includes 118 million for migrant minors. Critics point to the lack of budgets and to how the spending will actually be executed.
-
Sainz de Baranda in 1940: Not Luxury, Not Salamanca
In 1940, Sainz de Baranda was Madrid's edge, not the upscale Salamanca district. Mari Carmen’s flat wasn’t Móstoles either; her family arrived in 1957.
-
When did Winona Ryder turn into Isabel Coixet?
A birthday tweet for Winona Ryder sparks comparisons with Spanish director Isabel Coixet. The American actress was born on October 29, 1971.
-
Gemini justifies pedophilia in Spain case
Spain's 1973 Criminal Code set the age of sexual consent at 12. It was raised to 13 in 1995 and to 16 in 2015. Key facts about a case that was not a crime.
-
Iryo driver warned she could not restart the system
The Iryo driver reported she still could not connect the system and could not start the train. The high-speed train behind had already been given clearance to proceed.