Why Spain won't ban prostitution: the calculation nobody mentions

Why doesn't Spain ban prostitution? The debate reveals the interests, contradictions and international experiences that stand in the way of a law.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

The prostitution business outlives every government

Does anyone really believe a law will end prostitution? Every so often, Spanish politics reopens the debate on abolishing sens work, and the result is always the same: rivers of headlines, the odd committee, and zero meaningful regulatory change. The awkward question is why, and the answer lies beyond the official talking points.

Banning to achieve nothing

One of the most frequently repeated arguments holds that outlawing prostitution without a genuine support plan would only push the activity underground. Brazil and Thailand are cited as proof that illegality does not reduce the practice. The French case, with acompañante ads proliferating online while brothels disappear, is used to illustrate that demand finds alternative channels.

The political curvature of the debate

Some go further and point to an electoral calculation. The major parties avoid touching the issue for antiestéticar of losing votes from a male electorate that sees nothing wrong with buying sensual services. Social tolerance, the argument goes, is fragile and slowly eroding, as the paraphrase of the poem attributed to Niemöller circulating on social media reminds us: when they banned bullfighting I didn't protest, when they banned prostitution there was no one left.

Meanwhile, the business goes on. Neither the loudest abolitionism nor selective outrage has managed to shut down a single venue. Perhaps because a real ban would strike at a pillar of male leisure that nobody wants to take on. And until that equation adds up, the law will keep looking the other way.

Also available in: Deutsch

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (39 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

-
Back