Von der Leyen admits nuclear mistake: U-turn or confession?
Von der Leyen calls the nuclear phase-out a strategic mistake. Reactions range from demands for her resignation to claims of a Bill Gates ploy. A real U-turn or a new business deal?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Von der Leyen admits that shutting down nuclear plants was a strategic blunder
Can a single statement from the President of the European Commission change the course of the continent's energy policy? Three months ago, Ursula von der Leyen dropped a phrase few expected: "This reduction of nuclear energy was our decision... It was a strategic mistake." The confession, which came without fanfare or resignation, reopens the debate on Europe's nuclear shutdown and its consequences.
From blind faith in renewables to belated regret
For years, the official narrative bet on renewables as the natural replacement for nuclear power. But the facts have debunked the story. Dependence on Russian gas, price volatility and the intermittency of wind and solar have left Europe in a vulnerable position. Now, from the offices of Brussels to public opinion, people are hearing what many warned about: dismantling operational nuclear plants was energy suicide.
The reaction was not long in coming. While some demand political accountability — some outright her resignation — others see in this belated regret a manoeuvre to reposition Bill Gates' reactors, declared "green" when convenient. Scepticism is the dominant tone: the very people who pushed the green agenda now lament the mistake, but without bearing any costs.
The curious thing is that, in a democracy, strategic mistakes usually have a price. But here, those who made them remain in office. Perhaps the definition of "mistake" in Brussels is selective: citizens foot the bill and politicians offer the lament. Such are the ironies of the green transition.
Most shared
Related debates in the forum
Can a single statement from the President of the European Commission change the course of the continent's energy policy? Three months ago, Ursula von der Leyen dropped a phrase few expected: "This reduction of nuclear energy was our decision... It was a strategic mistake." The confession, which came without fanfare or resignation, reopens the debate on Europe's nuclear shutdown and its consequences.
From blind faith in renewables to belated regret
For years, the official narrative bet on renewables as the natural replacement for nuclear power. But the facts have debunked the story. Dependence on Russian gas, price volatility and the intermittency of wind and solar have left Europe in a vulnerable position. Now, from the offices of Brussels to public opinion, people are hearing what many warned about: dismantling operational nuclear plants was energy suicide.
The reaction was not long in coming. While some demand political accountability — some outright her resignation — others see in this belated regret a manoeuvre to reposition Bill Gates' reactors, declared "green" when convenient. Scepticism is the dominant tone: the very people who pushed the green agenda now lament the mistake, but without bearing any costs.
The curious thing is that, in a democracy, strategic mistakes usually have a price. But here, those who made them remain in office. Perhaps the definition of "mistake" in Brussels is selective: citizens foot the bill and politicians offer the lament. Such are the ironies of the green transition.
Most shared
Related debates in the forum
- Post-keynesianismo y escasez de recursos (peak-oil) · 71 replies
- La Economía de la Abundancia · 643 replies
- Red Eléctrica reconoce ahora que España vuelve a estar en riesgo inminente de apagón · 301 replies
- Terremoto en stellantis y miedo en vw · 228 replies
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (39 replies).
More summaries
-
EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen Hospitalized with Severe Pneumonia
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen is hospitalized with severe pneumonia, sparking mixed reactions ranging from concern to political satisfaction.
-
European Commission cuts AC for staff but not for commissioners
The European Commission switched off air conditioning on floors 1 to 7 of the Berlaymont building but kept cooling running on the floors of Von der Leyen and the commissioners.
-
Ukrainian Drone Strikes on Yandex Cripple Russian Bot Traffic
Ukrainian attacks on Yandex data centers in Vladimir, Sasovo and Kaluga have caused a sharp drop in Russian bot traffic, with reports of a 56% decline.
-
Inurrieta: central banks can create unlimited money, but at what cost
Economist Alejandro Inurrieta says central banks can create money without limit. Critics warn that inflation destroys purchasing power. Reality or trap?
-
Julio Iglesias sues eldiario.es and Nacho Escolar for defamation
Julio Iglesias is suing Nacho Escolar and eldiario.es for defamation. The financial cost and the legal precedent could change investigative journalism in Spain.
-
A midnight walk settles nothing in Ceuta's safety debate
A woman claims that walking alone at midnight in Ceuta proves there is no risk. The backlash on social media has turned it into a political debate.