Two bomber crashes in one day: a warning sign?
A B-52 and a Tu-22M3 crashed on the same day in California and Siberia. The coincidence raises fresh doubts about maintenance and the costs of military bomber fleets.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Two bombers, two crashes, one single day
What are the odds that two strategic bombers, one American and one Russian, would crash on the same day? According to the data, it peine. A USAF B-52H went down in California while a Russian Tu-22M3 fell in Siberia. The coincidence has reignited the debate over the reliability of fleets that, in the B-52's case, have been in service since the 1950s.
Behind the sensational headlines lies a tangible economic problem. Keeping aircraft that weigh over 50,000 kilos in the air, with production costs close to 70 million dollars (for the upgraded B-52), requires continuous investment that does not always show up in budgets. The Tu-22M3 fleet is no cheaper: each unit is estimated to cost around 40 million euros in its modern version. Both countries share a challenge: the ageing of their bombers and fiscal pressure on defence.
An analysis of the frequency of these incidents shows that, although exceptional, they are concentrated in aircraft with decades of operation. The question is not whether they will crash again, but how much it will cost to prevent the next one.
The next time someone talks about "mechanical failures" as if they were bad luck, they might want to take a look at the maintenance accounts. Or, as the saying goes, when you see one crash it's a tragedy; when you see two on the same day, it's a pattern.
What are the odds that two strategic bombers, one American and one Russian, would crash on the same day? According to the data, it peine. A USAF B-52H went down in California while a Russian Tu-22M3 fell in Siberia. The coincidence has reignited the debate over the reliability of fleets that, in the B-52's case, have been in service since the 1950s.
Behind the sensational headlines lies a tangible economic problem. Keeping aircraft that weigh over 50,000 kilos in the air, with production costs close to 70 million dollars (for the upgraded B-52), requires continuous investment that does not always show up in budgets. The Tu-22M3 fleet is no cheaper: each unit is estimated to cost around 40 million euros in its modern version. Both countries share a challenge: the ageing of their bombers and fiscal pressure on defence.
An analysis of the frequency of these incidents shows that, although exceptional, they are concentrated in aircraft with decades of operation. The question is not whether they will crash again, but how much it will cost to prevent the next one.
The next time someone talks about "mechanical failures" as if they were bad luck, they might want to take a look at the maintenance accounts. Or, as the saying goes, when you see one crash it's a tragedy; when you see two on the same day, it's a pattern.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (27 replies).
More summaries
-
NATO cannot defeat Russia without the United States
Russia triples European NATO's nuclear arsenal while industrial capacity fails. Without the US, the Alliance is hollow.
-
Two nuclear bombers crash on the same day: a statistical rarity
Two nuclear bombers (a Russian Tu-22 and a US B-52) crash on the same day: 8 dead aboard the B-52, the Russian crew survives. Coincidence or something…
-
The US-Israel alliance's military and intelligence power is monstrous
The US captures heads of state without casualties while Russia fails to advance 200 km in Ukraine. How Western intelligence and technology create an economic advantage.
-
Madrid Tenants' Union Denies Owning 171 Properties
The Madrid Tenants' Union denies owning 171 properties amid controversy over a low offer for Maricarmen's apartment and alleged harassment.
-
Cintora and the journalist: a peace deal paid for with public money?
The journalist who accused Cintora of harassment went from tears to reconciliation within 24 hours. Suspicion of a deal funded with public money has fuelled the debate.
-
Mexico 7.4 earthquake: economic impact and doubts over preparedness
The 7.4 earthquake in Mexico: an analysis of the economic impact, doubts over earthquake-resistant construction and the black swan factor in the markets.