Three children dead and a pink tide demanding the mother's acquittal
Three children dead, a mother on trial and a pink tide demanding her acquittal: the postpartum abortion debate and justice's double standard.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Three children dead and a pink tide demanding the mother's acquittal
The father came home from a night out with friends to find his vvife injured in the yard and his three children lifeless. In any other context, the scene would be a routine forensics case. But the rallies in support of the accused have turned this tragedy into a political battleground: the protest demands recognition of "postpartum abortion" as a pending right for women's freedom.
The debate: victim or perpetrator?
The defence deploys its full arsenal: depression, wrongly prescribed medication, negligence by social services, the husband's neglect. The slogan "the system failed her" is repeated like a mantra. Against this, the other side points out that the children received no help either, and that the "Bretón case" — a father convicted of killing his two children — was granted not a shred of that understanding.
The contrast fuels suspicion that justice applies a double standard. But it also raises an uncomfortable question: if mental illness is an excuse, why only when the accused is a woman? The slogan "no guilty woman, no responsible woman" waves on the placards. The courts, for now, have not ruled. But the echo of that protest has left a troubling question: where does understanding of mental illness end and gender-based impunity begin?
The father came home from a night out with friends to find his vvife injured in the yard and his three children lifeless. In any other context, the scene would be a routine forensics case. But the rallies in support of the accused have turned this tragedy into a political battleground: the protest demands recognition of "postpartum abortion" as a pending right for women's freedom.
The debate: victim or perpetrator?
The defence deploys its full arsenal: depression, wrongly prescribed medication, negligence by social services, the husband's neglect. The slogan "the system failed her" is repeated like a mantra. Against this, the other side points out that the children received no help either, and that the "Bretón case" — a father convicted of killing his two children — was granted not a shred of that understanding.
The contrast fuels suspicion that justice applies a double standard. But it also raises an uncomfortable question: if mental illness is an excuse, why only when the accused is a woman? The slogan "no guilty woman, no responsible woman" waves on the placards. The courts, for now, have not ruled. But the echo of that protest has left a troubling question: where does understanding of mental illness end and gender-based impunity begin?
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (13 replies).
More summaries
-
Spain: Social report alone secures 5-year rent aid for abuse victims
The Spanish government plans to let a social services report replace judicial proof for five years of state-funded rent for gender violence victims.
-
Abortion: prison in the Philippines and the unverified Russian subsidy
The Philippines punishes abortion with 2 to 6 years in prison; from Russia comes a claim of a subsidy covering up to 100% of a mortgage for having children. A range with no consensus.
-
Jury deadlocked in trial of mother who killed her three children
The jury has failed to reach a unanimous verdict against the mother at the trial for the murder of her three children. The tension between the proven facts and postpartum psychosis remains unresolved.
-
Ketamine: the drug slipping through Spain's DGT drug tests
In the Balearic Islands, saliva tests fail to detect ketamine, and professional drivers use it to evade police checks. The system's loophole...
-
Toronto shuts down comments on its 30 km/h tweet
Toronto disabled comments on its tweet about 30 km/h zones, citing terms of use violations after the conversation turned into personal attacks.
-
Feijóo reopens abortion debate in Spain and his party fears the cost
Alberto Núñez Feijóo has reopened the abortion and euthanasia debate in the middle of Spain's election campaign, while his own voters warn of the political cost of relitigating settled issues.