RTVE: Ayuso should face prison for pandemic deaths in Spain
An RTVE contributor calls for Ayuso's imprisonment over 7,291 nursing home deaths. Legal debates regarding central command and a Cáceres ruling add context.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The controversy over 7,291 nursing home deaths in Madrid: Ayuso or the central government responsible?
A contributor at RTVE claimed that Isabel Díaz Ayuso should be imprisoned for her responsibility regarding 7,291 deaths in nursing homes during the pandemic. The statement has peine the debate over who held command in managing these facilities during the state of alarm.
Nursing home protocols: Regional or state competence?
Real Decreto 463/2020, of March 14, declared the state of alarm and established a single command under the central Government. However, article 6 of the decree specified that the autonomous communities (Spain's regional governments) maintained the ordinary management of social services, including the coordination of nursing homes. This interpretation pits those who argue Ayuso had the decision-making power to prevent deaths against those who point to then-Vice President Pablo Iglesias as the ultimate person responsible.
The Cáceres ruling exculpating regional governments
A ruling by the Administrative Court No. 2 of Cáceres determined that civil liability for the sanitary management of nursing homes during the state of alarm rested with the central State and not the autonomous communities. The resolution, which exonerated a regional government in a claim for 159,110.87 euros, has become a key argument for Ayuso's defenders. Nevertheless, other voices point out that the Madrid protocol of not transferring elderly residents to hospitals was a regional decision that increased mortality.
The 7,291 figure: Exclusive to Madrid?
Data suggests that mortality in nursing homes was high across Spain, but Madrid concentrated the highest absolute number of deaths. Critics of Ayuso argue that her government issued orders not to saturate hospitals, prioritizing care within the nursing homes themselves. Her defenders remind us that the central Government's single command limited her scope for action and that other regions with different political leanings also recorded high rates.
Was Ayuso empowered to prevent these deaths, or was the Sánchez administration truly responsible? The answer remains open as no final judicial ruling has determined incivil liability.
Most shared
Related debates in the forum
A contributor at RTVE claimed that Isabel Díaz Ayuso should be imprisoned for her responsibility regarding 7,291 deaths in nursing homes during the pandemic. The statement has peine the debate over who held command in managing these facilities during the state of alarm.
Nursing home protocols: Regional or state competence?
Real Decreto 463/2020, of March 14, declared the state of alarm and established a single command under the central Government. However, article 6 of the decree specified that the autonomous communities (Spain's regional governments) maintained the ordinary management of social services, including the coordination of nursing homes. This interpretation pits those who argue Ayuso had the decision-making power to prevent deaths against those who point to then-Vice President Pablo Iglesias as the ultimate person responsible.
The Cáceres ruling exculpating regional governments
A ruling by the Administrative Court No. 2 of Cáceres determined that civil liability for the sanitary management of nursing homes during the state of alarm rested with the central State and not the autonomous communities. The resolution, which exonerated a regional government in a claim for 159,110.87 euros, has become a key argument for Ayuso's defenders. Nevertheless, other voices point out that the Madrid protocol of not transferring elderly residents to hospitals was a regional decision that increased mortality.
The 7,291 figure: Exclusive to Madrid?
Data suggests that mortality in nursing homes was high across Spain, but Madrid concentrated the highest absolute number of deaths. Critics of Ayuso argue that her government issued orders not to saturate hospitals, prioritizing care within the nursing homes themselves. Her defenders remind us that the central Government's single command limited her scope for action and that other regions with different political leanings also recorded high rates.
Was Ayuso empowered to prevent these deaths, or was the Sánchez administration truly responsible? The answer remains open as no final judicial ruling has determined incivil liability.
Most shared
Related debates in the forum
- Turns out Mazón was sleeping with Vilaplana during the DANA blackout · 253 replies
- Let's not forget this image from March 2020 · 124 replies
- He accompanied her to the parking lot and was disconnected for 37 minutes · 231 replies
- Is it normal to tell everyone to get lost as you get older? · 282 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (101 replies).
More summaries
-
Taberna Garibaldi: The 14-Euro Tapas That Ignite Debate
Pablo Iglesias' Taberna Garibaldi and the 14-euro tapa reopening the debate on consistency and business in its revolutionary menu.
-
Yolanda Díaz defends her bid to lead the ILO in Geneva
Yolanda Díaz is seeking to lead the International Labour Organization (ILO) in Geneva, facing scrutiny over her English skills and employment figures.
-
Spain's CUP rebrands itself to fight electoral collapse
The CUP is turning to a modern image to halt its decline, but a study by the CEO shows its voters travel more than Vox's, contradicting its rhetoric.
-
Abortion: prison in the Philippines and the unverified Russian subsidy
The Philippines punishes abortion with 2 to 6 years in prison; from Russia comes a claim of a subsidy covering up to 100% of a mortgage for having children. A range with no consensus.
-
Evangelical preachers on Madrid Metro: the carriage video
A passenger confronts two evangelical preachers on the Madrid Metro and the video reopens the debate over the use of public space inside train carriages.
-
Litter, scooters and phones: a map of urban irritation
Dog mess, spit, e-scooters, phones and groups blocking the whole pavement: how the annoyance of walking through the city breaks down.