Remains of the kings of Aragon evacuated as wildfire spreads in Spain
The hasty removal of the bones of the first kings of Aragon from a wildfire has drawn criticism over the improvised operation and the lack of proper resources.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Lightning evacuation of the remains of the kings of Aragon
The scene is unprecedented: the bones of the first Aragonese monarchs, rushed out of their resting place to escape the flames. The image of the removal, with the remains loaded as if they were ordinary cargo, has been enough for half of Spain to question whether the country knows how to protect what is its own.
The logistics of a controversial rescue
Criticism quickly focused on the resources used. There were no armoured vans or museum protocols; witnesses describe an ordinary SUV, a scene more befitting a household move than a historic heritage operation. The contrast with past episodes is inevitable: during the Alcázar fire, the Meninas were thrown out of the windows to save them; the difference is that there the fire was the enemy, and today, for many, the enemy is neglect.
Natural disaster or accumulated negligence?
The underlying debate goes beyond this episode. Some argue that no system can prevent every wildfire and that saving heritage is the logical thing to do. But others point out that these fires feed on unmanaged forests and an abandoned rural Spain, and that the lack of investment in prevention turns every summer into a game of Russian roulette. The discussion slides into the territorial model: for some, decentralisation has proven incapable of coordinating basic responses; for others, it is the central government that is failing.
The scene could happen again. And we will call it an emergency again, when in reality it is a pre-announced appointment with the lack of foresight.
The scene is unprecedented: the bones of the first Aragonese monarchs, rushed out of their resting place to escape the flames. The image of the removal, with the remains loaded as if they were ordinary cargo, has been enough for half of Spain to question whether the country knows how to protect what is its own.
The logistics of a controversial rescue
Criticism quickly focused on the resources used. There were no armoured vans or museum protocols; witnesses describe an ordinary SUV, a scene more befitting a household move than a historic heritage operation. The contrast with past episodes is inevitable: during the Alcázar fire, the Meninas were thrown out of the windows to save them; the difference is that there the fire was the enemy, and today, for many, the enemy is neglect.
Natural disaster or accumulated negligence?
The underlying debate goes beyond this episode. Some argue that no system can prevent every wildfire and that saving heritage is the logical thing to do. But others point out that these fires feed on unmanaged forests and an abandoned rural Spain, and that the lack of investment in prevention turns every summer into a game of Russian roulette. The discussion slides into the territorial model: for some, decentralisation has proven incapable of coordinating basic responses; for others, it is the central government that is failing.
The scene could happen again. And we will call it an emergency again, when in reality it is a pre-announced appointment with the lack of foresight.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (18 replies).
More summaries
-
Wildfire threatens the Monastery of San Juan de la Peña in Spain
The wildfire has been stopped just short of the Monastery of San Juan de la Peña, but the flames are already devastating its surroundings, leaving Aragon's heritage at the mercy of the wind.
-
Spain's Socialists collapse in Aragon as Podemos exits regional parliament
The PSOE in Aragon hits a historic low and Podemos loses its seat, while the PP consolidates and Vox surges in the regional election.
-
Mecca, the holy city showing its other face
Images of central Mecca show neglect just metres from the mosque while the Saudi palace erases historic heritage.
-
The snow leopard strikes again: who survives?
The snow leopard attacks again but its prey survives. A metaphor for economic resilience: rock, mountain goat and three months of supplies.
-
Central Madrid: the map that divides opinion on what it was and what it is
A debate over quality of life in central Madrid pits those who see it as degraded against those who rate it among the world's best. Data from a crowdsourced map fuels the row.
-
Repopulating with the 'unproductive': Spain's controversial empty housing plan
More than half of Spain's empty homes are in Galicia and Castilla-La Mancha. A plan proposes relocating the 'unproductive' there, but local opposition is fierce.