You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Petrol at 5 euros: the perfect storm nobody in Spain protested
Petrol at 5 euros, Euribor at 10% and inflation at 20%: the scenario that failed to bring Spaniards onto the streets. An analysis of Spain's paradox of social resignation.
Petrol at 5 euros: the perfect storm nobody in Spain protested
How do we end up in a scenario where petrol hits 5 euros, the Euribor reaches 10% and inflation hits 20%, and the social response is a deafening silence? Around four years ago, economic debate in Spain reached levels of pessimism that now seem prophetic. Forecasts pointed to a convergence of soaring prices that would blow apart consumption, housing and disposable income. And yet the streets never burned. Or almost.
The price cocktail nobody wanted to see
The figures being bandied about then painted a bleak picture: petrol at 5 euros a litre, Euribor at 10% and inflation at 20%. A trio that, in theory, should have paralysed household finances. Yet social protest was conspicuously absent. The argument was that citizens were demobilised, caught between a political class they saw as out of touch and an opposition that alternated between sterile confrontation and complicity with the government. Neither the trade unions nor the parties managed to mount a mass response.
The figure that changed everything: the fall in gas prices
Amid the doom-mongering, one piece of data emerged: commodity prices were starting to fall. Gas, in particular, plunged 14% in a single day. For some analysts, that movement signalled the beginning of the end of the inflationary spiral. But distrust of the official narrative was such that many saw it as a manoeuvre to cool criticism on the eve of the NATO summit. The crisis narrative was entangled with geopolitics.
The paradox of resignation
The most striking thing was not the price, but the absence of a reaction. While the cost of living soared, citizens kept flocking to café terraces for two-hour beers, but without spending beyond that. The irony did not go unnoticed: cheap entertainment had become the norm in expensive times. The explanation doing the rounds was that Spanish society had exhausted its capacity for surprise and its will to protest, overwhelmed by one crisis after another. And perhaps also because the potential leaders of any protest were too busy with their own internal battles.
The lessons of a storm that never broke
That debate, which today looks like an exercise in futurology, exposed something uncomfortable: when economic indicators turn extreme, society reacts with less urgency than the models assume. Or perhaps the reaction was subtler, channelled into political disaffection and the rise of anti-establishment rhetoric. The truth is that petrol at 5 euros did not spark barricades, but it did leave a simmering discontent that still lingers. And that, in terms of social resilience, is just as unsettling as the crisis itself.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (21 replies).
The Supreme Court confirmed Paqui Gento's parentage. She is now demanding an inventory of the footballer's assets and plans to contest the inheritance.
Iran defies the West with its history of resistance, its nuclear alliance with North Korea and a culture of martyrdom. The keys to a country that refuses to bow.
Russian soldiers are using anti-tank mines as demolition charges to blow up Ukrainian positions. The low-cost tactic is challenging expensive Western equipment.
Kim Jong-un mocks free speech in the United Kingdom and offers refuge to Britons fleeing Starmer's 'dictatorship'. A joke, or a reflection of a real trend?