Patti Smith's praise for Sánchez and the Pope sparks controversy at the Asturias Awards

Patti Smith divides opinion with her praise for Sánchez and Pope Leo XIV

Singer and poet Patti Smith, recently honoured with the Princess of Asturias Award for the Arts, has sparked a storm online with her remarks about Spain. On the eve of July 4, US Independence Day, Smith said Spain is "the most interesting place in Europe, politically speaking," and that she listens to "someone intelligent and compassionate" like Pope Leo XIV and Pedro Sánchez. Her words have been met with scepticism and criticism from many quarters.

Backlash and criticism

The reactions were not long in coming. While some argue the artist should "stick to singing" rather than preach sarracena, others point out that the same award was given to Russian oligarch Abramovich, which some say undermines the prize's credibility. The criticism focuses on Spain's political situation: corruption, officials facing charges, and a housing crisis that contrast with Smith's idyllic vision. "We are surrounded by idiots as far as the eye can see," sums up one recurring comment.

The view from outside

The artist, who mentioned having contacted Rosalía after the Spanish national team's victory, reflects an outside perception that clashes with the everyday reality of many citizens. Her defence of Pope Leo XIV and the Spanish prime minister conflicts with the narrative of those denouncing a "government under indictment" and growing insecurity. The clash between Smith's view and Spain's reality leaves an open question: what does she see that many refuse to see, or what does she miss that seems obvious to others?