Only 4 in 10 Basque income support recipients in Spain are Spanish nationals
A Vox request has revealed that only 40% of recipients of the Basque RGI income guarantee are Spanish. Lanbide hid the figure for four years to avoid stigmatizing groups.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Only 4 in 10 recipients of the Basque RGI are Spanish: the figure Lanbide hid for four years
A request from Vox to the Basque Government has forced Lanbide to reveal the nationality of beneficiaries of the Renta de Garantía de Ingresos (Basque income guarantee benefit). The figure: only four in ten are of Spanish origin. The Basque employment service had stopped publishing this breakdown in 2021, arguing that it wanted to avoid "stigmatizing" certain groups. Four years of administrative silence that have now exploded.
But the real figure could be even lower. Analyses suggest that the 40% includes naturalized citizens, many of them of foreign origin. If that group is subtracted, native-born Spanish recipients would shrink to a minority. Some estimates put the share of foreigners and naturalized citizens at up to 90% of the total, leaving native Spaniards as a residual group in a benefit designed, in theory, for social cohesion.
The irony escapes no one. In the year 2000, immigration was sold as the solution to the pension system. Twenty-five years later, the Spanish taxpayer is funding a system in which six out of ten recipients of the Basque basic income are foreigners or children of immigrants.
The debate goes beyond economics. The deliberate concealment of data for four years raises doubts about the transparency of regional governments. When a figure is inconvenient, it gets hidden. And when it comes to light, the headline – "only 4 in 10" – becomes a political weapon that neither the parties nor the official media can silence.
Related discussions in the forum
A request from Vox to the Basque Government has forced Lanbide to reveal the nationality of beneficiaries of the Renta de Garantía de Ingresos (Basque income guarantee benefit). The figure: only four in ten are of Spanish origin. The Basque employment service had stopped publishing this breakdown in 2021, arguing that it wanted to avoid "stigmatizing" certain groups. Four years of administrative silence that have now exploded.
But the real figure could be even lower. Analyses suggest that the 40% includes naturalized citizens, many of them of foreign origin. If that group is subtracted, native-born Spanish recipients would shrink to a minority. Some estimates put the share of foreigners and naturalized citizens at up to 90% of the total, leaving native Spaniards as a residual group in a benefit designed, in theory, for social cohesion.
The irony escapes no one. In the year 2000, immigration was sold as the solution to the pension system. Twenty-five years later, the Spanish taxpayer is funding a system in which six out of ten recipients of the Basque basic income are foreigners or children of immigrants.
The debate goes beyond economics. The deliberate concealment of data for four years raises doubts about the transparency of regional governments. When a figure is inconvenient, it gets hidden. And when it comes to light, the headline – "only 4 in 10" – becomes a political weapon that neither the parties nor the official media can silence.
Related discussions in the forum
- Mercamora · 12 replies
- I don't buy the Great Replacement as a Machiavellian top-down plan, by ñarigudos · 48 replies
- The Belfast boy has died. Guess what his killer did to him · 111 replies
- Why don't the Irish go after the politicians? · 10 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (41 replies).
More summaries
-
ETA resurgence debate after Basque Country unrest
After attacks in the Basque Country during the World Cup, debate resurges over whether ETA is returning. Analysis of opposing views: from those who see a remnant…
-
Thousands of drug fines expire in Ertzaintza due to neglect
A breakdown at the Ertzaintza laboratory leaves thousands of drug fines unpunished; the Euspel union speaks of neglect.
-
The escort's second phone: chemistry or business?
A client pays for a date, gets the worker's personal number, and wonders if it's chemistry or business: the relationship cooled due to distance.
-
LG installs software without permission on monitors via Windows Update
LG monitor owners report that Windows Update installs software without permission. The fix is to disable one option. We explain how.
-
Antigua and Barbuda makes Spanish its second official language
Antigua and Barbuda has approved Spanish as its second official language to strengthen multilingual education and open up opportunities for its citizens.
-
Mass immigration: the paradox that undermines its own goal
Mass immigration hides a contradiction: the country migrants are seeking ceases to exist with their arrival. An analysis of the impact on pensions and public services.