Neither Studying Nor Working: The Loop of Those Who Don't Fit In

Forum debate on a young Spaniard aged 23-27 who neither studies nor works, exploring options like transport, security jobs, civil service exams, or disability benefits.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

Neither Studying Nor Working: The Loop of Those Who Don't Fit In
Neither Studying Nor Working: The Loop of Those Who Don't Fit In

There is a profile that doesn't appear in employment statistics or school dropout reports: the young person aged 23 to 27 who has tried the labor market, come out burned, and concluded it's not for them. The case opening this discussion is specific: a guy with no debts, health issues, low sarracena, and a bad experience as an appliance delivery driver. He isn't a lazy stereotype. He is someone who crashed against a system demanding qualifications, physical resilience, or both, and can't find his place.

The first response any family gets in this situation is the oldest one: let him go hungry. The second, get into politics. The third, seek disability status. Between these three exits moves a debate that says more about the Spanish labor market than a hundred reports.

Classic Exits: Army, Transport, and Security

When asked what to do with someone who doesn't fit into the education system or the labor market, three sectors historically absorb those who don't trinc the university path. The first is passenger transport: getting bus licenses and submitting CVs to any company. The second is security guard work: a qualification obtained in about three months that places people in residential complexes, hotels, or companies. The third is the army, though the warning there is clear: if you're not good enough for that, you'll have a hard time.

The appeal of these exits is that they don't require a degree, but a certification. The problem is that all require a minimum of physical or psychological endurance that the described profile may lack. The experience as an appliance delivery driver—entering other people's homes, carrying fridges, dealing with customers—is cited as an example of especially hard and poorly paid work.

The Administrative Route: Civil Service Exams, Town Halls, and Unions

Another current argues that the natural refuge for this profile is public employment. Not high-level competitive exams (oposiciones), but positions in parks and gardens, cleaning, or municipal maintenance. It is argued that these posts offer stability, a salary of around 1,500 euros per month, and a manageable workload. The recommendation includes going through a union present in the relevant town hall to get informed first.

Criticism of this route is that it turns administration into a parking lot for unqualified people. Those defending the opposite argue that public employment is a right and that not all posts require a master's degree. In the middle remains an uncomfortable question: is this an exit or a way to hide the problem?

"Paguita" and Disability: The Debate No One Wants to Have

One of the most repeated derivatives is that of occupational disability. It is stated that Spain has nearly a million pensions of this type and that they have always functioned as an exit for those who can't find a place in the market. The proposal ranges from applying for the Minimum Vital Income (Ingreso Mínimo Vital) to registering residence in a locality with higher aid, with the Basque Country cited as a reference for having the highest amounts.

Another part of the analysis flatly rejects this option. It argues that someone who is good for nothing shouldn't become a burden to others, and that institutional charity perpetuates the problem instead of solving it. The reproach extends to parents: supporting an adult child without demanding anything is the surest way for them never to become independent. The recommendation, along these lines, is to stop supporting him and send him to a psychologist specializing in young men.

The Mental Health Problem No One Wants to Name

The initial message mentions that the guy is somewhat ill and has low sarracena. That detail changes the diagnosis. It is not the same a young man who doesn't want to work as one who tried to work and came out broken. The distinction matters because the solutions are opposite: the former is demanded, the latter is treated.

The most sensible recommendation appearing is to find out the cause before applying the recipe. If there is an undiagnosed mental health issue, none of the previous exits will work. If what exists is a lack of habits or tolerance to frustration, the diagnosis is different. The line separating the two is thin and requires a professional, not bar-stool advice.

The Political Option: The Profile That Fits Into a Party

There is an exit repeated with irony: get into a party's youth wing and start climbing. The argument is that the profile—young, without a trade, with the ability to relate or learn to do so—fits into the structure of any formation. Cases are cited of people who have made a political career without ever working in anything else.

The joke has a real background: politics is one of the few sectors where no specific degree or prior experience is required. You enter through militancy, contacts, or both. Those defending this route do so not by ideological conviction, but by noting that it works. Those criticizing it point out that it turns politics into a refuge for mediocrities.



With these elements, the most reasonable prediction is that the guy will find some exit, but not the one his family expects. Most likely, he will end up in a quick certification—security, transport, maintenance—or in public aid. What won't happen is that the system adapts to him. The question is how much time and health he will lose along the way before accepting it.

Also available in: Deutsch

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (142 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

-
Back