Merz fails chancellor vote, fracturing German CDU coalition
Friedrich Merz missed the majority by six votes in his first Bundestag investiture. The CDU-SPD coalition holds 328 seats but faced internal dissent.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Merz fails investiture, leaving CDU on brink of split
Friedrich Merz will not become Chancellor of Germany, at least for now. The German conservative fell six votes short of the required majority in the first investiture vote in the Bundestag, an unprecedented event in the history of the Federal Republic. He needed 316 supporters and received 325 according to some counts, falling below the threshold in others, despite a CDU+CSU+SPD coalition holding 328 seats. The math doesn't add up: someone from his own ranks didn't press the button.
The result leaves the Christian Democrat leader in an awkward position. His coalition agreement with the German Social Democrats included more immigration, more debt, less industry, and higher military spending, a program that, according to the most repeated analysis, amounts to adopting the SPD's agenda just to govern. The paradox is that even with those concessions, it wasn't enough.
What Article 63 of the Basic Law says
Article 63 of the German Basic Law stipulates that if the candidate is not elected, the Bundestag can choose a chancellor within the next 14 days trinc the vote. In this second round, a simple majority suffices. This means Merz could still become chancellor, but backed by a more fragile majority and labeled as having stumbled in the first attempt.
Voting in the Bundestag is secret, so there is no way to know who voted against him. This fuels all kinds of theories. The most widespread among observers is that someone within the CDU itself had a crisis of conscience and refused to sign off on what they consider the destruction of the country. Another interpretation points to the SPD: socialist MPs may have voted against to extract more concessions in the new government, more positions, and more ministries.
The SPD already has almost everything it asked for
If the coalition agreement already incorporates the social democratic program on nearly every point, the question is what else the SPD might want. The circulating answer is simple: plum jobs. Positions, chairs, power quotas. German politics enters a phase where programs matter less than distribution.
Some go further, arguing that all this is a rehearsed charade. That the German CDU-SPD coalition (analogous to Spain's PP-PSOE) is staging a crisis to appear not to be partners. The thesis has its logic: if voters punish conservatives for partnering with social democrats, it helps to make it look like they are doing so reluctantly.
The Romanian precedent and antiestéticar of the polls
In the background lies what peine in Romania, where a similar coalition failed and voters punished traditional parties. Antiestéticar of the ballot box is real. The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) is the leading party in voting intentions in some polls, changing the rules of the game.
The most repeated hypothesis is that if Merz ends up governing with support from the Greens, the CDU will explode internally. And that would guarantee the AfD an absolute majority in the next elections. The other hypothesis is that the AfD will be banned during the legislative term to avoid repeating these votes. "Long live memocracy," some summarize.
A system not as exemplary as it seems
The German political system has its cracks. The Bundestag approved a constitutional change to allow increased military spending using sitting MPs, weeks after the elections. A complete fraud, according to the most critical reading. And now it turns out that the investiture can be toppled by a few secret votes.
Party discipline, that invention, is exposed when voting is anonymous. In Spain, it is called party discipline and applied with an iron fist. In Germany, with secret voting, each MP votes according to their conscience or their pocketbook. Or both.
What could happen now
Merz has 14 days to try again. He can be elected in the second round by simple majority, which practically means he will govern in a minority or with ad hoc support. His weakness is marked for everyone, inside and outside Germany.
The question hanging in the air is whether the CDU will hold together or end up making a pact with the AfD, something that was previously a red line. If it does, the coalition with the SPD collapses. If it doesn't, the AfD will continue growing in the polls. Is there any way out that doesn't involve breaking something?
Friedrich Merz will not become Chancellor of Germany, at least for now. The German conservative fell six votes short of the required majority in the first investiture vote in the Bundestag, an unprecedented event in the history of the Federal Republic. He needed 316 supporters and received 325 according to some counts, falling below the threshold in others, despite a CDU+CSU+SPD coalition holding 328 seats. The math doesn't add up: someone from his own ranks didn't press the button.
The result leaves the Christian Democrat leader in an awkward position. His coalition agreement with the German Social Democrats included more immigration, more debt, less industry, and higher military spending, a program that, according to the most repeated analysis, amounts to adopting the SPD's agenda just to govern. The paradox is that even with those concessions, it wasn't enough.
What Article 63 of the Basic Law says
Article 63 of the German Basic Law stipulates that if the candidate is not elected, the Bundestag can choose a chancellor within the next 14 days trinc the vote. In this second round, a simple majority suffices. This means Merz could still become chancellor, but backed by a more fragile majority and labeled as having stumbled in the first attempt.
Voting in the Bundestag is secret, so there is no way to know who voted against him. This fuels all kinds of theories. The most widespread among observers is that someone within the CDU itself had a crisis of conscience and refused to sign off on what they consider the destruction of the country. Another interpretation points to the SPD: socialist MPs may have voted against to extract more concessions in the new government, more positions, and more ministries.
The SPD already has almost everything it asked for
If the coalition agreement already incorporates the social democratic program on nearly every point, the question is what else the SPD might want. The circulating answer is simple: plum jobs. Positions, chairs, power quotas. German politics enters a phase where programs matter less than distribution.
Some go further, arguing that all this is a rehearsed charade. That the German CDU-SPD coalition (analogous to Spain's PP-PSOE) is staging a crisis to appear not to be partners. The thesis has its logic: if voters punish conservatives for partnering with social democrats, it helps to make it look like they are doing so reluctantly.
The Romanian precedent and antiestéticar of the polls
In the background lies what peine in Romania, where a similar coalition failed and voters punished traditional parties. Antiestéticar of the ballot box is real. The far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) is the leading party in voting intentions in some polls, changing the rules of the game.
The most repeated hypothesis is that if Merz ends up governing with support from the Greens, the CDU will explode internally. And that would guarantee the AfD an absolute majority in the next elections. The other hypothesis is that the AfD will be banned during the legislative term to avoid repeating these votes. "Long live memocracy," some summarize.
A system not as exemplary as it seems
The German political system has its cracks. The Bundestag approved a constitutional change to allow increased military spending using sitting MPs, weeks after the elections. A complete fraud, according to the most critical reading. And now it turns out that the investiture can be toppled by a few secret votes.
Party discipline, that invention, is exposed when voting is anonymous. In Spain, it is called party discipline and applied with an iron fist. In Germany, with secret voting, each MP votes according to their conscience or their pocketbook. Or both.
What could happen now
Merz has 14 days to try again. He can be elected in the second round by simple majority, which practically means he will govern in a minority or with ad hoc support. His weakness is marked for everyone, inside and outside Germany.
The question hanging in the air is whether the CDU will hold together or end up making a pact with the AfD, something that was previously a red line. If it does, the coalition with the SPD collapses. If it doesn't, the AfD will continue growing in the polls. Is there any way out that doesn't involve breaking something?
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (146 replies).
More summaries
-
Germany's Beer Purity Law: Protection or Rip-off?
The 1516 Purity Law banned corn and rice in beer. Today, Spanish brands use them. Rip-off or economic necessity? Prices, margins and...
-
Merz defends immigration while Blackrock is under the microscope
German Chancellor Merz defends immigration as sustaining the job market, amid growing criticism of his past association with Blackrock.
-
Martin Varsavsky details luggage theft from German guests in Barcelona
Entrepreneur Martin Varsavsky reports the theft of documents, bags and laptops from German guests in Barcelona, adding: "I thought this way before. Not anymore."
-
Spanish Lawyer Begoña Gerpe Moves to Andorra After Hate Speech Complaint
Begoña Gerpe relocates her tax residence to Andorra following a complaint filed with the Prosecutor's Office over a YouTube video.
-
Soros celebrates Lula's win in Brazil
Alex Soros celebrated Brazil's election result on X with a message of support for Lula. We look at what he said and why his opinion carries weight in the markets.
-
Vitoria: €2,454 in benefits and an eviction that ends on the street
A family with six children receives €2,454 in benefits and is evicted in Vitoria, Spain, while the landlord lives in a rented room with his pregnant wife.