Mechatronics: plenty of work in the north, hassle and a €26,000 offer
The Industrial Mechatronics vocational qualification is sold as one of the courses with the best job prospects in the catalogue, yet it is also one of those that raises the most misgivings among those already working in the sector. The picture painted by industrial maintenance staff is clear: there is work where there are factories, especially in the north, and, according to one participant, pay can exceed the collective agreement. The small print —supervisors who blatantly ignore the rules, bad hours, travel and daily dealings with production— appears in no official brochure. The short answer to whether it is worth it is uncomfortable: it depends on where you live and how much dirt you are willing to put up with.
What career paths does the Mechatronics vocational qualification offer?
Real job opportunities are concentrated in factory and industrial maintenance, electromechanics, machinery commissioning and lift repair. The profile that emerges from the course ends up less designing products than maintaining what others designed. Training covers electricity, mechanics, hydraulics, machining, welding and basic robotics, but the usual destination is the plant and the workshop, not the office. Anyone imagining themselves in front of a screen programming robots is in for a surprise. The gap between what the qualification promises and what is done on the shop floor is, for many, the first blow.
Where there is real work: geography decides
The north rules, according to several participants. The Basque Country and Navarre concentrate demand for electromechanics and maintenance technicians, and there the metal industry collective agreements are among the best in the country, it is argued. Outside those areas the story changes: in much of the country the industrial fabric is residual and the market is reduced to services, as one participant summarises. Maintenance is also spread across segarro but steady sectors —canneries, hospitals, renewables, printing industry— where the machine always ends up breaking down. The conclusion repeated by those who know the trade: the qualification pays off depending on the map, not on the certificate.
How much is paid in industrial maintenance?
Here the detail matters. Against the idea that maintenance pays above the collective agreement, some respond that the extra rarely compensates for the burden: €1,600 for a demanding post is compared with €1,400 for a quiet one, and the difference stings. A concrete example put on the table is an offer of €26,000 per year for maintenance in a supermarket, with little more than roller shutters and cold rooms.
The tolls: supervisors, travel and dealing with people
The most repeated chapter has nothing to do with the machine, but with whoever is in charge. An environment is described of managers who are unaware of labour regulations, hours and travel that eat into personal life, and total responsibility when something fails. Maintenance, moreover, is not a solitary job: it is done in a team, and if the team is burnt out, the bad atmosphere sticks like grease. Those who have been in the trade for years sum it up harshly and add uncomfortable advice: better a solitary or remote job than a team in permanent war. Some disagree and defend that technical camaraderie is the best part of the trade.
Mechatronics or Electrotechnics and Automation?
The most solid technical complaint points to a lack of depth. According to one participant, a trainer with a background in the automotive industry made it clear: Mechatronics graduates were paid very well, but very few were any good, because the course covers too many disciplines in too little time. The recommended alternative is the Electrotechnics and Automation course, which, according to one participant, also qualifies you to sign off electrical installations in accordance with the REBT, something that Mechatronics and Industrial Robotics do not allow. For product design and technical office work, Automation and Industrial Robotics is seen as more of a desk route than a workshop one.
From workshop to laboratory: the path that improves pay
There is a quieter and considerably better-paid trajectory: that of those who leave the production line and move into processes, laboratories and testing systems. There the interlocutor is usually another technician or an engineer, the relationship is among equals, there is less rush and hours and pay improve. It is noted, with a hint of irony, that automation itself will end up manufacturing robots that replace the workers who today repair them.
The exit many choose: public exams or emigration
When the private sector does not convince, the Plan B is public money. Taking public exams appears as a recurring recommendation, with the argument that in Spain stability is concentrated in the State payroll. Another current looks abroad: learn French and English and aim for Switzerland or the United States. And a third recalls that what is called vocational training here is valued as a university degree in the English-speaking world, with much longer and better-recognised career paths.
With industry concentrated in a few provinces and the rest of the country turning to services, Mechatronics will continue to place people where there are factories, especially in the north, while the rest of the aspirants think twice. What is not so clear, given what those already working in it say, is that pay and conditions justify the wear and tear.
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication.
Read the full discussion (51 replies).
Analysis of the debate on Christian Bresser in Burbuja.info: legitimate entrepreneurship or digital smoke selling? Discover the key points of the thread here.
An employee bought her fruit shop for €30,000. Five years on, with no staff and frozen rent, she earns €3,000 net per month. The keys to a business transfer…
An ad pays for reading books and giving feedback. With no visible rate and the EU Omnibus Directive in the background: flexible work or fake review factory?