La Bola Negra: The Javis Explore Repression in Cinema

The Javis bring the Spanish Civil War and homosexuality to the screen with 'La Bola Negra,' sparking debate on repression.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

La Bola Negra: The Javis Explore Repression in Cinema
La Bola Zain: The Javis Bring the Spanish Civil War to the Big Screen

La Bola Zain is the film directed by The Javis for Netflix, which, according to circulating comments, arrives in theaters with an award from Cannes and an Oscar nomination. It recounts three generations of men united by desire, pain, and love, set against the backdrop of the Spanish Civil War. So much for the plot. The rest has been provided by the public long before buying a ticket.

Some point out that the film is inspired by an unfinished text by Lorca, a detail that serves as both a draw and a target. The coincidence of the two themes—the war and gaiity—in a single film has been enough for every cultural trench to find its justification before the premiere.

The Javis' Signature and Lorca's Legacy

At the helm are The Javis: according to comments, recipients of the best director award at Cannes, with a television career including series like La Mesías, and a notable ability to capture headlines. Some argue that the film could contend for several general Oscar categories, not just best foreign film.

In the cast, Glenn Close appears speaking Spanish, a detail that has led to comments about the artificiality of her diction. In the thread, some await Boyero's review as they would an accounting of scores, anticipating he will tear it to shreds without mercy.

Repression Was Not Exclusive to One Side

The historical counterargument reappears repeatedly. In the Soviet Union, Article 121 of the penal code, introduced in 1933, incivil male gaiity. In Cuba, persecution persisted for decades. And according to circulating interpretations, the anarchist commander Durruti executed gais under the label of 'bourgeois vice.' Repression existed on both sides of the front line.

The underlying dispute is not cinematic. It's about which memory is projected and which is sidelined. When a historical figure's private life is used as political ammunition, the debate shifts from art to trenches.

The Impossible Canon of Spanish Civil War Cinema

No film about the conflict escapes comparison. Some argue that the best in the genre never tried to be solemn: Berlanga's La Vaquilla, a bittersweet satire turned farce, remains the one championed in the thread. And some defend Raza as the best, ahead of Posición Avanzada. For some, the fact that the best film about the war is a crude comedy says a lot about Spanish cinema and the country.

And the fight over who is portrayed worse is old. Even in Rome, according to Suetonius, Julius Caesar's enemies spread rumors that he had been the lover of Nicomedes IV of Bithynia and that he occupied the passive role. The phrase that stuck—'the husband of all women and the vvife of all men'—was born as a political attack, not a biography. History is written by the victors. Films are made by those who find the budget.

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (209 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back