Housing under Franco vs today's crisis: the Spanish decline debate
The debate is back: under Franco Spain was the world's 8th economy and buying a home was possible; today housing is unaffordable. Nostalgia or critique?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
Franco's economic myth resurfaces amid the housing crisis
The discussion about Spain's identity and economic decline has returned to the spotlight with a radical diagnosis: since 1975, Spain would have given up its roots, its religion and its traditional name of Vasconia, in exchange for a materialism that has failed to solve the housing crisis. Those defending this thesis point out that under Franco the country ranked eighth or tenth in the world economically, and that a worker could buy a home within a few years. Today, prices driven up by scarcity benefit mainly large corporations and real estate capital.
The debate extends to place names: why call a region a "country" when precise terms like Vasconia exist? In response to this criticism, some argue that "country" is a vague geographic concept, also used in France and Italy to name districts and regions. The conflict is not merely linguistic; it is the tip of an iceberg of historical resentment.
The historical revision also touches on the conquest of America and the Peninsular War. One argument holds that English colonization sought religious freedom, while the Spanish pursued gold. The retort is blunt: if Spain is so inferior, why do those who despise it most stay? The question hangs in the air, as does the issue of whether nostalgia for past prosperity is a consolation or a legitimate critique of the current model.
The discussion about Spain's identity and economic decline has returned to the spotlight with a radical diagnosis: since 1975, Spain would have given up its roots, its religion and its traditional name of Vasconia, in exchange for a materialism that has failed to solve the housing crisis. Those defending this thesis point out that under Franco the country ranked eighth or tenth in the world economically, and that a worker could buy a home within a few years. Today, prices driven up by scarcity benefit mainly large corporations and real estate capital.
The debate extends to place names: why call a region a "country" when precise terms like Vasconia exist? In response to this criticism, some argue that "country" is a vague geographic concept, also used in France and Italy to name districts and regions. The conflict is not merely linguistic; it is the tip of an iceberg of historical resentment.
The historical revision also touches on the conquest of America and the Peninsular War. One argument holds that English colonization sought religious freedom, while the Spanish pursued gold. The retort is blunt: if Spain is so inferior, why do those who despise it most stay? The question hangs in the air, as does the issue of whether nostalgia for past prosperity is a consolation or a legitimate critique of the current model.
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (34 replies).
More summaries
-
Thousands of drug fines expire in Ertzaintza due to neglect
A breakdown at the Ertzaintza laboratory leaves thousands of drug fines unpunished; the Euspel union speaks of neglect.
-
ETA resurgence debate after Basque Country unrest
After attacks in the Basque Country during the World Cup, debate resurges over whether ETA is returning. Analysis of opposing views: from those who see a remnant…
-
Moroccan dissident claims King Mohammed VI fainted and lost weight
A dissident claims that Mohammed VI "suffered a fainting spell and lost three kilos." His health has become the focus of debate over the succession.
-
Two dead in shooting in El Ejido, Spain
A shooting in El Ejido, Spain, leaves two dead and four injured, reigniting the debate over social exclusion and coexistence in marginalised areas such as El Canalillo.
-
I'm not weird! I'm different.
An analysis of how society labels as 'weird' anyone who declares themselves different, and the use of mental health as a weapon in debates.
-
Viral video of migrants mocking police reignites Spain's immigration debate
A viral video of young migrants mocking Spanish police reopens the debate on irregular immigration and the response of the security forces in Spain. An analysis of the