Girauta Claims Tusk Uses 'Rule of Law' as Empty Slogan

Juan Carlos Girauta argues in El Debate that Donald Tusk, the Polish Prime Minister, uses the phrase "Rule of Law" as an empty rhetorical device, disconnected from any genuine defense of legal principles. The article, published on November 9, 2026, also attacks what the author describes as Tusk's pro-European Union alliance.

Columnist **Juan Carlos Girauta** publishes an article in **El Debate** dated **November 9, 2026**, targeting Polish Prime Minister **Donald Tusk**. The piece blends discourse analysis with political criticism, titled "Tusk as a pet." It claims Tusk has reduced his rhetoric to the repetitive use of the English term "Rule of Law," which translates to Estado de Derecho in Spanish.

## Thesis: An expression that fills everything

Girauta characterizes Tusk's speeches as a sequence where "Rule of Law" appears repeatedly, separated only by filler words serving a protective function. He compares this to bubble wrap used for porcelain: once the packaging is removed, only the prestigious phrase remains. The author asserts that this repetition does not correspond to any reality Tusk genuinely defends.

The article provides no transcripts or specific dates for these speeches. The accusation relies on a rhetorical characterization of the figure rather than documentary evidence. Readers seeking verifiable examples of such interventions will not find them in the text.

## Criticism of the "pro-EU alliance"

The columnist places Tusk within what he calls the old and corroded "pro-EU alliance," a term he says refers to those in the **European Union** who work toward dissolving Europe's culture, tradition, and values. He cites multicultural policies as outcomes of this alliance and briefly mentions the difficulties young people face in gaining independence and accessing housing.

The piece blames this alleged destruction on a "German-obedient" alliance, positioning Tusk as its most compliant pet. The term "pet" appears in the title and recurs in the body as a derogatory label for the Polish Prime Minister.

## Merkel, Russian gas, and German dependency

The article devotes a section to **Angela Merkel**, accusing her of making Germany dependent on Russian gas, shutting down nuclear and coal plants, and accepting 1.5 million Syrians "in one go." These claims are presented without sources or elaboration. The figure of 1.5 million is stated as a closed fact, lacking nuance regarding the timeframe or counting method.

Girauta speculates that Merkel was "an East German spy activated after reunification." This hypothesis is framed as personal belief, not documented fact. The article concludes by warning that Germany is "circulating through Poland again" and suggests that those who fail to see this lack historical awareness.

## Key takeaways

This text is an opinion column, not an investigation. Its informational value lies in the stance it takes: it accuses Tusk of hollowing out the concept of Rule of Law through repetition and positions him at the center of broader criticism against the EU and German influence. Verifiable facts are scarce; characterizations and suspicions dominate the content. It should be read as what it is: a signed opinion piece with a clear thesis and limited documentary support.