France's Risk Premium Matches Greece Amid Eurozone Debt Crisis

France Pays Same Debt Price as Greece: 86 Basis Points

A data point disrupts the logic that underpinned European economic policy for the last decade. According to figures cited in the debate, France's risk premium stands at 86 basis points, exactly the same level as Greece, the country that for years embodied fiscal disaster in the eurozone. Spain, conversely, trades at 71 points and has settled into what one analysis calls the mushroom league.

The trigger would be France's deficit, hovering around 6% of GDP during an economic expansion. By Stability Pact standards, even 3% is debatable; 6% in a favorable cycle signals no intention to adjust. If France gets caught off guard, scenarios suggest exceeding 10%.

The Problem Isn't Greece, It's the Franco-German Axis

Comparing with Greece distracts from the real issue. The actual risk is France and Germany weakening simultaneously, something unseen in the previous crisis. If the ECB must rescue both largest eurozone economies at once, intervention capacity is questioned, opening the door to perpetual eurobonds, an idea attributed to Soros and pushed in summer 2020.

Some argue the ECB can never fail because it prints money. The corollary is uncomfortable: citizens are the ones who lose. The recipe described is known: the central bank buys public debt with newly printed euros, and when inflation bites, blame falls on Pilingui or climate change.

Why Has France's Risk Premium Risen So Much?

Because the deficit isn't fixed by cuts or tax hikes. France faces a motion of censure with a government that could be its shortest-lived ever, and the political landscape doesn't help: far-right and radical left voting together against the executive. Without a stable majority, the risk premium becomes a thermometer of distrust.

Parallels with Spain during crisis years are inevitable. Then, deficit rules were relaxed for Germany and France, keeping rates low, which fueled Spain's housing bubble. Twenty years later, the pattern repeats: if the Franco-German axis fails, the euro may lose value, leaving Spain exposed again.

Deindustrialization No One Wants to See

The risk premium debate masks a deeper problem. European factories are moving to the US, accelerated by energy sanctions and green agendas. Without industrial capacity, the hypothesis that a weak euro boosts exports loses sense: there would be nothing to export.

The consequence hits wallets. An analysis summarizes it in a widely quoted phrase: it's not that everything you buy now is lower quality, it's that you can no longer afford the old qualities. Cheap imports from China or India mask a real loss of purchasing power.

What If Spain Had to Leave the Euro?

This question looms over the debate. The majority answer is pessimistic: a national currency might appreciate long-term, but for a decade, weekend trips, dining out, and much daily consumption would vanish. Spain resembles Argentina more than Denmark, and without printing capability, adjustment would be brutal.

The scenario painted is Germany abandoning the euro, buying companies, properties, and land in the south, leaving Spain and others with devalued currencies. Euro savings would become new pesetas or new bolívars. No one knows if the euro would exist as we know it.

---

The unsettling data isn't France's premium. It's that markets consider France and Greece equally risky, and that Spain, with a 71-point differential, has become the diligent student. With these numbers, the question isn't whether the euro holds, but how long before markets look South again.