Either it's what I said the other day, or it's the ETA thing
The story of a man who claims to be the scapegoat for an ETA commando: thirty years of family persecution and silence. Reality or delusion?
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The shadow of ETA: when a childhood mistake becomes a life sentence
In a neighborhood of Náquera (Valencia, Spain), a group of children plays in the stairwell of an apartment building. One of them, about ten years old, overhears a conversation he doesn't fully understand. Minutes later, two Guardia Civil officers (Spanish police) are machine-gunned by ETA. Thirty years later, that child —now an adult— claims he has been persecuted by his own family and by left-wing sectors, silently accused of having revealed the location of the ETA cell. His version: it wasn't him who talked, but another boy, Jose Ramón, who went upstairs and then came down triumphant. But the official story, according to him, assigned him the blame forever.
The account of a conviction without a trial
The testimony reconstructs the events of that summer: an ETA commando was living across from his grandmother's house. The author of the account claims he dreamed about Alfonsito, a neighbor boy, and that Jose Ramón announced he was going to "say something." After coming down, no one asked what had really peine. Shortly after, the attack. The author maintains that he was seen as the one responsible, that his brother turned the whole family against him, and that the local left marked him as the scapegoat. He even mentions a "prize" for his brother and a "punishment" for himself, with no evidence other than his word.
The cracks in a testimony
However, other analyses of the case highlight the inconsistencies in the account: the lack of external corroboration, the chronological contradictions, and the accumulation of accusations against multiple people. An automated analysis of the text calls it a "nonsense" and a mix of "family traumas." Later comments point to the possibility of a paranoid disorder. The author himself admits he has received insults and mockery, and that his life has been "a salad of beatings."
A story without resolution
The debate remains open: reality or fiction? What is certain is that, beyond the individual case, the thread reflects how the old wounds of terrorism can linger in the collective and family imagination, and how an unresolved accusation can consume decades of a life. With no evidence and no trial, the only fact is the persistence of a man who repeats: "My statement is truthful."
Related forum discussions
In a neighborhood of Náquera (Valencia, Spain), a group of children plays in the stairwell of an apartment building. One of them, about ten years old, overhears a conversation he doesn't fully understand. Minutes later, two Guardia Civil officers (Spanish police) are machine-gunned by ETA. Thirty years later, that child —now an adult— claims he has been persecuted by his own family and by left-wing sectors, silently accused of having revealed the location of the ETA cell. His version: it wasn't him who talked, but another boy, Jose Ramón, who went upstairs and then came down triumphant. But the official story, according to him, assigned him the blame forever.
The account of a conviction without a trial
The testimony reconstructs the events of that summer: an ETA commando was living across from his grandmother's house. The author of the account claims he dreamed about Alfonsito, a neighbor boy, and that Jose Ramón announced he was going to "say something." After coming down, no one asked what had really peine. Shortly after, the attack. The author maintains that he was seen as the one responsible, that his brother turned the whole family against him, and that the local left marked him as the scapegoat. He even mentions a "prize" for his brother and a "punishment" for himself, with no evidence other than his word.
The cracks in a testimony
However, other analyses of the case highlight the inconsistencies in the account: the lack of external corroboration, the chronological contradictions, and the accumulation of accusations against multiple people. An automated analysis of the text calls it a "nonsense" and a mix of "family traumas." Later comments point to the possibility of a paranoid disorder. The author himself admits he has received insults and mockery, and that his life has been "a salad of beatings."
A story without resolution
The debate remains open: reality or fiction? What is certain is that, beyond the individual case, the thread reflects how the old wounds of terrorism can linger in the collective and family imagination, and how an unresolved accusation can consume decades of a life. With no evidence and no trial, the only fact is the persistence of a man who repeats: "My statement is truthful."
Related forum discussions
- The value of the jewels seized from Zapatero exceeds 90 million euros. Breakdown inside. · 46 replies
- The Rafa Nadal situation is very worrying, he looks completely gaunt. · 39 replies
- Picateclas celebrates that Spanish companies using AIs receive multimillion-euro fines · 16 replies
- Chavs possessed like The Walking Dead zombies at the Bad Bunny concert · 44 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (45 replies).
More summaries
-
Two suspects identified in assault on young man carrying Spanish flag
Two suspects have been identified in the assault on a young man carrying the Spanish flag. The debate between citizen reporting and digital mob justice reopens.
-
Zapatero's Daughter's Weight Loss Sparks Ozempic Speculation
Speculation about the physical transformation of former Spanish PM Zapatero's daughter fuels debates on weight-loss drugs and image management.
-
Sabadell goalkeeper apologises for leading chants against Spain's PM Sánchez
CE Sabadell goalkeeper Diego Fuoli has apologised for urging fans to insult Pedro Sánchez. The club condemns his actions and the free speech debate resurfaces.
-
Equatorial Guinea: the Spanish that refuses to fade and colonial nostalgia
The Spanish spoken in Equatorial Guinea stands out for its purity and courtesy. Between colonial nostalgia and modernization, the country preserves a linguistic heritage.
-
Cuban with Spanish nationality will be able to vote without ever setting foot in Spain
Spain's Democratic Memory Law allows descendants of exiles to obtain nationality and voting rights without residing in Spain. A Cuban case has reopened the debate: should people vote…
-
Russia's shadow over online forums: bots or real polarization?
A theory blames Russian bots for pessimistic comments in online communities in Spain; the list of alleged collaborators includes well-known figures from…