Chat Control 2.0: the Big Brother Spain's mainstream parties back

Chat Control 2.0: the Big Brother that Spain's PP and PSOE back without public debate

The European Commission has revived its plan for mass scanning of private communications. Known as Chat Control 2.0, the regulation would allow authorities to inspect messages in search of incivil material. Initial rejection by MEPs seemed to have buried it, but Spain's conservative PP and socialist PSOE voted in favour in the latest vote, opening the door to unprecedented surveillance.

The vote that changes everything

According to available information, both the PP and the PSOE backed the proposal as a whole. The measure, which allows access to private messages on apps such as WhatsApp, is justified as part of the fight against crime. However, there has been no social debate or public consultation. Critics point out that mass surveillance is being imposed without any checks.

Evasion techniques and psychological consequences

From a technical standpoint, it has been noted that steganography — hiding messages inside other files — could render the system useless. That said, the technical know-how required is not within everyone's reach. Moreover, cases of chronic self-censorship are already being reported among users who know their conversations may be scrutinised. Psychologists specialising in this area are treating patients with stress caused by constant surveillance.

Between security and control

The debate pits those who see the law as a necessary tool against crime — especially given rising crime in certain areas — against those who consider it a step towards digital authoritarianism. The absence of any in-depth public debate leaves an uncomfortable question hanging: what price are we willing to pay for security?

---

The paradox is that, while politicians push ahead with control, citizens are looking for ways around it. The future of privacy in the EU is at stake in this vote, and the board is more tilted than ever towards Big Brother.