AfD and BSW Negotiate Europe's First Anti-Establishment Government

AfD and BSW are negotiating in Saxony-Anhalt for Europe's first anti-mainstream government: nuclear energy, Russian gas, and immigration curbs.

English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published

AfD and BSW Negotiate Europe's First Anti-Establishment Government
AfD and BSW Negotiate Unprecedented Government in Saxony-Anhalt

Saxony-Anhalt is one of those German states that most people wouldn't be able to place on a map. Now, it threatens to become the continent's political laboratory: the far-right AfD and the left-wing BSW are negotiating a governing coalition that would be Europe's first anti-mainstream executive. What unites two parties that despise each other fits into three folders — energy, immigration, and Ukraine — and a cold calculation of how long their voters will hold out before everything blows up.

What Unites AfD and BSW in Saxony-Anhalt?

Restoring nuclear energy, reopening the Russian gas tap, and reducing everything to legal and regulated immigration. That would be the minimum program both parties would be willing to sign in this eastern German state. In foreign policy, they even agree more: both advocate stopping financial aid to Ukraine, a point that shatters the consensus Berlin and Brussels had taken for granted.

The fit isn't automatic. A current of analysis highlights the underlying contradiction: BSW comes with an agenda of subsidies and social protectionism, while AfD sells tax cuts and liberalism. Marrying them will be the first real clash. Some add another nuance: BSW is electrorally weaker than AfD among its own audience, leaving it in the position of a junior partner and, therefore, with less room to impose its agenda.

Why the Case is Being Watched from Spain

The parallel is drawn by domestic observers themselves: if in Germany the new right and the new left make pacts, why not here? The most repeated comparison is with the Frente Obrero (Workers' Front), which some see presenting a candidacy even in Podemos primaries to capture the disillusioned vote of the left-wing electorate. Others directly dismiss the analogy: Spain is not Saxony-Anhalt, and the labels of left and right fly out the window as soon as immigration or leaving the euro is discussed.

Underlying this is the suspicion that the entire party system is a charade. PP and PSOE would be, according to this reading, two sides of the same coin, and the parties presenting themselves as alternatives end up being crutches for power, as — according to criticism — peine to Podemos with PSOE.

The Standoff with Brussels: Can Funds Be Cut?

The most repeated hypothesis is that the European Union and the German establishment will try to suffocate the experiment financially, starting by cutting transfers to this state. It's not a confirmed scenario, but it is the escape route many consider a foregone conclusion. If the laboratory works, the domino effect towards the rest of Germany — and towards Europe — ceases to be science fiction.

The unknown that no one can close remains: how long will a marriage between two projects that need each other to govern and hate each other to exist last? The answer, for now, is up in the air.

Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (50 replies).

More summaries

All summaries in English →

Back