23 bison turn Chihuahua's barren desert into a thriving grassland
23 bison transform the Chihuahua desert into grassland. Is extensive grazing the solution politicians ignore? We look at the debate on Burbuja.
English · Original discussion in Spanish · Published
The miracle of 23 bison in the Chihuahua desert
Can desertification be reversed with just 23 bison? The experiment in the Janos Biosphere Reserve defies the experts' logic, as they predicted immediate disaster given the lack of irrigation or artificial assistance. While the official narrative usually demonises livestock over methane, this case in Chihuahua suggests that extensive grazing, applied methodically, is the key to recovering grasslands that seemed doomed to dust.
Extensive grazing vs. the methane dogma
On the forum, the discussion quickly turned to criticism of political and corporate management. Many users point out that there is a self-interested confusion between intensive livestock farming — the big farm model — and extensive farming, which imitates the natural cycles of wild fauna. While some forum members denounce a "straw man fallacy" by those who criticise the methane of wild cattle, others point out that the real problem is the lack of pasture rotation, citing cases where human intervention without method has ended up wiping out areas that were once fertile.
The culture war behind ecology
The thread has ended up becoming a battleground over land management in Spain. The comparison with "empty Spain" and the ironic (and not so ironic) proposal to repopulate with Quaternary megafauna has exposed the rift between those who trust in nature's capacity for regeneration and those who see a hidden agenda in any environmentalist measure. The question that remains without a clear answer is whether the Chihuahua success is replicable or whether, as the most sceptical suggest, this is an isolated case that cannot be transferred to other ecosystems without constant human intervention.
Are we looking at a real solution for land-use change or just an anecdotal experiment that serves to fuel the culture war on the forum?
Related debates on the forum
Can desertification be reversed with just 23 bison? The experiment in the Janos Biosphere Reserve defies the experts' logic, as they predicted immediate disaster given the lack of irrigation or artificial assistance. While the official narrative usually demonises livestock over methane, this case in Chihuahua suggests that extensive grazing, applied methodically, is the key to recovering grasslands that seemed doomed to dust.
Extensive grazing vs. the methane dogma
On the forum, the discussion quickly turned to criticism of political and corporate management. Many users point out that there is a self-interested confusion between intensive livestock farming — the big farm model — and extensive farming, which imitates the natural cycles of wild fauna. While some forum members denounce a "straw man fallacy" by those who criticise the methane of wild cattle, others point out that the real problem is the lack of pasture rotation, citing cases where human intervention without method has ended up wiping out areas that were once fertile.
The culture war behind ecology
The thread has ended up becoming a battleground over land management in Spain. The comparison with "empty Spain" and the ironic (and not so ironic) proposal to repopulate with Quaternary megafauna has exposed the rift between those who trust in nature's capacity for regeneration and those who see a hidden agenda in any environmentalist measure. The question that remains without a clear answer is whether the Chihuahua success is replicable or whether, as the most sceptical suggest, this is an isolated case that cannot be transferred to other ecosystems without constant human intervention.
Are we looking at a real solution for land-use change or just an anecdotal experiment that serves to fuel the culture war on the forum?
Related debates on the forum
- Members of the Spanish Flotilla arriving at Bilbao airport · 99 replies
- Today's Holy Gospel. Sunday, 24 May, "Send forth your Spirit, Lord, and renew the face of the earth" ***********************Holy Rosary at 22.00 · 11 replies
- The 'Right to the Loo' movement is born to end queues in women's bathrooms and to redesign these spaces · 19 replies
- Guess the actress from the Betty Boop film · 77 replies
Also available in: Deutsch
Summary of a discussion on Burbuja.info - Foro de economía, actualidad y política., translated from Spanish and reviewed before publication. Read the full discussion (63 replies).
More summaries
-
Mutilba case: Wife's 'shock' defense faces scrutiny
Carmen Mutilba, a licensed skipper, drifted for three days without calling for help after her husband fell overboard. Skepticism grows.
-
Fisherman dies after failing to cut engine in time
A 66-year-old fisherman fell overboard and his boat drifted away. His wife heard "turn off the engine" but couldn't react. What the case reveals about safety at sea.
-
Brad Pitt's San Sebastián Look: €14,000 or €14 at Pepco
Brad Pitt arrived in San Sebastián sporting an outfit valued at over €14,000, including a Zegna jacket priced around €9,000. The same look at Pepco would cost just €14.
-
Spanish minister María Jesús Montero makes bizarre mouth grimaces at a rally
Footage of María Jesús Montero grimacing at a rally has sparked wild theories on Burbuja.info, from drug use to demonic possession. Enter the thread
-
Amego segarro enjoys a tasty ice cream in Torremolinos
A viral video shows a Pakistani man beating a Moroccan man in Torremolinos, Spain. The scene, with a Chinese man in the background, sparks a debate about immigration, justice and the S
-
Cyclist loses it and punches a woman on the road
A viral video shows a cyclist punching a woman in the middle of the road. The debate over road rage and the factors that trigger it reopens.