Burbuja.info - Foro de economía > > > The pain in Spain will follow years of rapid economic gain
Respuesta
 
Herramientas Desplegado
  #1  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 21:18
Alatriste Alatriste está desconectado
Lisensiado burbujista
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 24-diciembre-2006
Mensajes: 609
Gracias: 0
5 Agradecimientos de 4 mensajes
Do current account deficits matter inside a monetary union? The answers are “no” and “yes”: no, because there cannot be a currency crisis; and yes, because there cannot be a currency crisis. Where unsustainable divergences in competitiveness emerge, adjustment occurs largely through changes in relative nominal costs, particularly of labour. The bigger the required adjustment, the greater the pain.

The challenge posed by divergent competitiveness inside the eurozone has been widely discussed for the case of Italy. But Spain is even more interesting. Spain, unlike Italy, has been an enormous economic success; Spain, unlike Italy, has a huge current account deficit; Spain, unlike Italy, has enjoyed a vast construction boom. But Spain, this time like Italy, has low productivity growth and deteriorating external competitiveness.

The question, then, is not whether adjustment will happen, since it is sure to do so. It is how it will happen.

Between 2001 and 2005, the eurozone was the sick giant of the world economy. Over those five years, eurozone growth averaged a mere 1.4 per cent a year. In response, the European Central Bank adopted an expansionary monetary policy. But the impact of low interest rates was greatest not where demand was weakest, but where conditions for a property boom were best: notably, in Ireland and Spain (see chart).

Spain’s overall economic performance has been of a kind certain to generate euphoria. As the latest economic survey from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development notes: “the country has experienced a 13th consecutive year of strong growth. The economic vitality has had the effect of narrowing the gap in per capita gross domestic product with the euro area average from 20 per cent to under 12 per cent over the past decade”.

This impressive expansion has been driven, on the supply side, by huge increases in employment, including of immigrants. Between 1998 and 2006, employment contributed 3 percentage points of the 3.5 per cent annual rise in Spain’s potential GDP and productivity just 0.5 percentage points. The contribution of “factor productivity” – or the increase in the efficiency with which factors of production are used – was negative, at -0.2 percentage points a year.







Meanwhile, on the demand side, domestic consumption and investment, particularly construction, have driven the economy. Between 2002 and 2006, construction grew at an average rate of close to 6 per cent a year, in real terms. By 2004, investment in new housing alone accounted for 8 per cent of GDP, a figure surpassed among OECD members only by Ireland.

Meanwhile, the foreign balance deteriorated year by year (see chart). Last year’s current account deficit of $107bn was the second largest in the world after the US. At just under 9 per cent of GDP, it was also the second largest in the eurozone on this measure, after that of Greece. Indeed, without Spain’s deficits, the eurozone would have had a sizeable current account surplus, largely reflecting Germany’s move into surplus, and so would have exacerbated the global “imbalances” (see chart).

“So what?” one may reasonably ask. Why should the emergence of so-called imbalances inside the eurozone be of any greater significance than the balance of payments between Scotland and England? Indeed, are the huge capital flows that are the counterpart of the current account surpluses and deficits not what the creation of a currency union is designed to achieve?

In the absence of currency and expropriation risk, investors seek the best returns where they are to be found. If that ends up generating large net borrowing by people living in a given country (or region), that is surely of no significance.

Up to a point, this argument is correct. But if investors are unaware of the interdependence of the risks they are running, they may find that their debtors are significantly less creditworthy than they had thought. More precisely, lenders into a construction boom are likely to find that a downturn in the local property market affects the solvency of many debtors. They may then decide to withdraw credit or stop providing new credit quite suddenly. If so, that will lead to a regional recession, as construction activity contracts.

Thus, inside a monetary union, currency risk turns into credit risk. Again, even widespread bankruptcy may not matter much if wages and prices are reasonably flexible in nominal and real terms, or it is easy to expand production of competitive tradeable goods and services. Adjustment then is relatively straightforward, as experience in east Asian and Nordic economies has shown in the not too distant past.

In such cases it is at least relatively easy to replace the lost domestic demand with foreign demand. But it is hard to be confident that this would be true of Spain when the property and construction booms end, for six reasons, all of which emerge from the OECD report: first, Spain has suffered a sizeable loss in competitiveness (see chart); second, the technological capacity of Spain’s tradeable goods industries is weak, on many dimensions; third, much of Spain’s recent investment effort has gone into the production of non-tradeables, particularly buildings; fourth, Spain’s industries are relatively vulnerable to competition from cheaper wage producers in central and eastern Europe and Asia; fifth, underlying productivity growth has been low, which will make it harder to restore competitiveness; and, finally, wage bargaining is quite rigid and, above all, unresponsive to conditions in the eurozone.

Spain has enjoyed a wonderful boom at a time of weak eurozone demand and expansionary monetary policy. As the eurozone recovers, monetary policy is being tightened. While Spain will benefit from the greater demand among its principal partners, its borrowers will face a substantially greater debt-service burden. That must bring closer the point at which the remarkable property-related borrowing and construction booms will end. Then adjustment will have to begin and Spain’s politicians will have to manage all the consequences.

For Spain, better times for the eurozone presage a much bigger challenge to itself. Adjustment to a different and more sustainable path will be required. A decade or so from today we should have a far better idea than today of how far one of Europe’s hitherto most successful economies is able to thrive within the straitjacket of the currency union.

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/16e554ac-dc8...b5df10621.html


Responder Citando
  #2  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 21:28
caosman caosman está desconectado
Becario de Trichet
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 24-enero-2007
Mensajes: 303
Gracias: 18
25 Agradecimientos de 9 mensajes
Que pena que tengan que venir de fuera para despertarnos....

Por cierto que el gráfico del balance por cuenta corriente me hace recordar las palabras de Zapatero...!n el 2010 adelantamos a Alemania! quins collons!!!

Saludos


Responder Citando
  #3  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 21:31
GloriaT GloriaT está desconectado
Bloguero del FT
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 08-octubre-2006
Mensajes: 175
Gracias: 2
49 Agradecimientos de 12 mensajes
Completamente demoledor. Se puede decir más alto, pero no más claro. En resumen, que S-pain lleva todas las papeletas para que le toque la rifa y mientras tanto, los "responsables" políticos mirando a Burgos...


Responder Citando
  #4  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 21:47
Dolmen Dolmen está desconectado
Idealisto
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 02-octubre-2006
Mensajes: 718
Gracias: 106
70 Agradecimientos de 29 mensajes
Leo esto mientras escucho en directo a Zapatero diciendo que hemos crecido más que los EEUU, más que..., más que...

¡Qué pena de país!


Responder Citando
  #5  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 22:01
euriborde euriborde está desconectado
Ilustrísimo y grandísimo miembro de la élite burbujista
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 01-septiembre-2006
Ubicación: Madrid, Tetuán
Mensajes: 5.445
Gracias: 200
1.230 Agradecimientos de 477 mensajes
me gustaría estar fuera de España para ver lo que va a pasar como espectador, no como reparto


Responder Citando
  #6  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 22:15
caosman caosman está desconectado
Becario de Trichet
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 24-enero-2007
Mensajes: 303
Gracias: 18
25 Agradecimientos de 9 mensajes
Iniciado por euriborde
me gustaría estar fuera de España para ver lo que va a pasar como espectador, no como reparto

Ya te digo, como la guerra del golfo, que la veiamos en TV, en plan video juego, todos esos tomahawk y scuds, con esos puntitos corriendo a lo lejos (que resulta que era gente asustada).
Aqui nosotros seremos esos puntitos...huyendo de los pepitohawk y de las scudpotecas...( y la ONU pasando de nosotros, que el tocho apaño no cotiza como el petróleo...)

Y aun queremos ganar el mundial!!!!jajajaja


Responder Citando
  #7  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 22:18
ellison ellison está desconectado
Burbujista abducido
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 02-febrero-2006
Mensajes: 2.546
Gracias: 532
1.774 Agradecimientos de 717 mensajes
todos los que estáis respondiendo hasta ahora (con los tópicos de siempre): cuántos os habéis leído entero el artículo?

-es curiosidad-

saludos


Responder Citando
  #8  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 22:23
pacomer pacomer está desconectado
Excelentísimo, ilustrísimo, magnífico y grandísimo señor de élite de los gurús burbujistas
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 15-enero-2007
Mensajes: 14.700
Gracias: 4.480
28.578 Agradecimientos de 7.345 mensajes
without Spain’s deficits, the eurozone would have had a sizeable current account surplus, largely reflecting Germany’s move into surplus, and so would have exacerbated the global “imbalances” (see chart).


Vamos que somos una carga para Europa poco mas o menos. A destacar del articulo lo que ya hemos defendido aqui reiteradamente, el corte del grifo crediticio pondrá la puntilla definitiva a una economía que ha crecido gracias a los ahorros de alemanes y franceses, sin el euro ibamos a crecer una leche y con el euro nos arruinaremos, no hay salida.

Última edición por pacomer; 27-mar-2007 a las 22:25


Responder Citando
  #9  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 22:24
caosman caosman está desconectado
Becario de Trichet
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 24-enero-2007
Mensajes: 303
Gracias: 18
25 Agradecimientos de 9 mensajes
Iniciado por ellison
todos los que estáis respondiendo hasta ahora (con los tópicos de siempre): cuántos os habéis leído entero el artículo?

-es curiosidad-

saludos

no se ingles, vale...mas pillao!!!


Responder Citando
  #10  
Antiguo 27-mar-2007, 22:33
nixganush nixganush está desconectado
Astrocotoc
 
Fecha de Ingreso: 02-enero-2007
Mensajes: 107
Gracias: 0
0 Agradecimientos de 0 mensajes
Iniciado por ellison
todos los que estáis respondiendo hasta ahora (con los tópicos de siempre): cuántos os habéis leído entero el artículo?

-es curiosidad-

saludos

Yo.

Aunque no había respondido hasta ahora. Pero ahí va:

Spain has enjoyed a wonderful boom at a time of weak eurozone demand and expansionary monetary policy. As the eurozone recovers, monetary policy is being tightened. While Spain will benefit from the greater demand among its principal partners, its borrowers will face a substantially greater debt-service burden. That must bring closer the point at which the remarkable property-related borrowing and construction booms will end. Then adjustment will have to begin and Spain’s politicians will have to manage all the consequences.

Mi respuesta está en las negritas. Ya sé que son los tópicos de siempre, pero por eso me limito a hacer mías las palabras del analista económico del Financial Times...


Responder Citando
Respuesta

Herramientas
Desplegado


Temas Similares
Tema Autor Foro Respuestas Último mensaje
The Economist : The pain IS Spain sanchez_paus Burbuja Inmobiliaria 16 26-dic-2010 10:06
U.S. Stock Futures Pare Gain After Spain’s Credit Outlook Is Cut Eddy Burbuja Inmobiliaria 9 10-dic-2009 01:11
The pain in Spain … RedSixLima Burbuja Inmobiliaria 2 20-ene-2009 23:05
The pain in spain... again (part II) charliness Burbuja Inmobiliaria 23 20-ene-2009 17:13
The Pain In Spain THE TIMOS Burbuja Inmobiliaria 0 16-ene-2008 14:16


La franja horaria es GMT +1. Ahora son las 23:33.